Wednesday, January 23, 2008


KDE 4 Review - Insane Style



So KDE 4 is out, along with major architectural changes, a new face, and new software, as well as tweaks to what KDE 3 had.

Now if you wanted to know about all the new libraries, and new platforms supported, or kinds of other flashy changes they made, you can look elsewhere on the internet. Instead I'm going to just describe the changes to the standard file open dialog, and the ramifications of having Dolphin as the new file manager, keeping in tradition of the previous file dialog articles.

So without further babbling, here's the new file open dialog:


Now ignoring all styling issues for the time being, let us compare that to what KDE 3.5 did:


First big difference is that the KDE 4 file dialog now has a crumb view on top. The crumb view is nice, in that if you want to jump back up a few directories, you can do so in a single click, instead of pressing up multiple times.

In fact you don't even need an up button anymore, but don't worry, the design experts at KDE gave you one anyway, since space on that line isn't important. Because if it was important they might consider moving the encoding drop down elsewhere - oh wait they did do that.

You've got to love mixed messages when it comes to GUI design, they needed more room for the crumb browser so they moved the encoding elsewhere to take up a full line down below, yet leave in the up button. Also interesting to note that KDE 4 is now using Qt 4, which quite nicely offers a file system watcher for paths to tell when they get updated to automatically refresh a file view, it seems despite that, the KDE team thinks you also need a nice refresh button on top.

Now if they really wanted to manage space properly, perhaps they'd put the crumb navigation on a line by itself up top, instead of giving all that room to encoding drop down which doesn't need a fraction of the room it's getting. Maybe something along the lines of this mockup I just made in KolourPaint:


Now there's plenty of room for large paths for the crumb browser, and no ridiculously huge encoding selector.

But these obvious issues aside, we haven't even gone past the surface of how utterly useless the dialog has become.

Remember how I spoke about how Windows added annoying virtual locations? Seems KDE copied them down the last annoying detail. Now "/home/insane" appears as "Home" in the crumb viewer (and no absolute path anywhere). If I want to go up to "/home", and then "/home/spouse", it's impossible. "Home" is treated as a root path, even to the extent that the unneeded up button doesn't do anything at this point either. One has to click on the left on "Root", then select "/home". This gets worse if you're on a machine where home directories are stored several levels deep. Of course power users, can type in the full path in the location bar on the bottom, but you'd think a group as intelligent as KDE can avoid glaring Windows design flaws. Don't even get me started on what happens if you delete the Root button from the quick locations on the left. Poor users who want to find someone else's home directory now have to navigate through the root path filled with stuff like "usr", "opt", "bin", "srv", and other unintelligent gibberish to do something that once was a single button click.

And speaking of annoying locations. Why the heck is Trash a location that appears by default in the quick locations? How often do you decide that the document you need to open is in the trash? I'm glad they removed Desktop, but replacing it with Trash? What were they thinking? Give me something useful like a Media quick link, for optical drives and all kinds of USB/Firewire external memory devices. They also completely removed support for right clicking on the quick locations panel, and just adding a new quick location. Now one is forced to drag a directory's folder icon from the right to the left. I wonder how that will work if one is in some kind of virtual directory that has no parent, making it impossible to drag.

Anyways regarding other features, remember how KDE 3 gave the user a lot of power and allowed them to have something similar to the old Windows 3 split view?


For some reason this useful method to navigate your files is completely gone.
And now with the old location input bar merged into the one for files, I can't even easily edit the current location by hand, since it doesn't display the current path at all. Furthermore, entering a new path seems to make it have useless data left over in it like the last path directory component after enter is pressed.

Old KDE file browser: 10
New KDE file browser: 6

I guess making the perfect file browser, especially when you were almost there is next to impossible.

Speaking of file browsers, lets look at how the new edition of Dolphin fares, touted as being better than Konqueror for simple management of files.

Now I remember I complained to some KDE devs a while back regarding the KDE 4 betas and how Dolphin seemed to be a bit brain damaged at file management, but they assured me it would change for the final release of KDE 4.0, and change it did! For the worse.

Back in the older betas, one could click a button to bring up a full path editor instead of the crumb view, now that button is completely gone. To bring it up, one has to go browse through one of the menus on top to switch back and forth between the quick browsing methods.

Here too, they also kept the brain damaged virtual Home path. There is no way to go up. Nice to see they didn't put in a useless up button, but here again, if I want to see everyone's home directory, I have to navigate there from Root.

Also, if one switches to the classic path editor, if one wants to go up, they're forced to backspace the old path, or switch back to the crumb view, since in the KDE Dolphin developers' great vision, they couldn't stick both views in at the same time, or make an up button appear when in the classic path editor.

There's also no nice directory and file split view here like good ol' File Manager. But one can bring up a directory tree browser:

And in keeping with the new KDE 4 design goal of copying stupidity from Windows (Vista), when viewing the tree view, the file viewing pane is also filled with now redundant directory listings.

Isn't it wonderful to see how people who used to be way ahead of the curve and tried so hard to offer a really advanced product have completely fell between the cracks when it came to normal sane usability of files?

For those of you wondering if perhaps GTK got any better since the last time I reviewed it, you can rest assured that it has not. In fact, I now have a new refined hatred for how lousy GTK is. In the course of uploading some images from FireFox in an article I was writing, the GTK file menu had the file type filter locked to (*.png/*.bmp/*.gif/*.jpg/*.jpeg). Since the pictures I had were all *.JPG, none showed up, as GTK in their infinite wisdom made the extension filter case sensitive.

Seems UNIX file management is just as lousy as ever and getting worse. I'm afraid to even look at Konqueror in KDE 4, fearing they ruined it too.

Feel free to start a flame war in the comments, I got my flame retardant suit on, besides nothing you can write can make me feel worse than what a downgrade KDE went through.

52 comments:

fliptw said...

It amazes me how some linux dev's think that copying MS's UI choices verbatim, without any consideration is a good thing.

It also annoying how they broke something that didn't need a lot of fixing.

Anonymous said...

do you think they will change it to something better in a subsequent release or is it hopeless because they will want to get people familiar with their existing setup.

insane coder said...

They change a lot based on feedback, so if we make a point of complaining how we really want certain features that are missing, I believe they will put them back.

Spread the word.

Sven said...

Yes! Why put so much effort in destroying a file manager. Was it not for the bizarre file "manager" I could even use gnome. As it is now it is completely useless. Every attempt I have made using it has resulted in files copied and opened in a close to perfect random manner. Not long ago I realized I have stopped using all the software using this file "manager", e.g. gimp and firefox. Still, perhaps the gnome "manger" can be used as a cautionary example for the KDE developers (or give them a good laugh).

aep said...

failure. pure failure. thanks for summing it up. Now we have some hard facts to throw at the gnome-qt4 trolls

Dan said...

Nice to see that you're back to writing. It is shocking to see them copying a far inferior system rather than perfecting the near-exemplary one they already had. I'm shocked and appalled! As always, wife, kids, yada yada yada.

Paul said...

I was always reluctant on doing it, but it looks like the KDE devs are going to force me to switch to xfce ...
For a real file manager, KRUSADER is the best I've come by so far. (gosh how I miss DOS + norton commander...)

Dave said...

It's my understanding that Dolphin is intended to be an absurdly simple file manager. The attitude I've heard is that Konqueror can still be a file manager, if you prefer.

As for Konqueror, there are some nice improvements, depending on how you look at it... The spinner has now been moved up to the menu bar, which means it's invisible to me most of the time. The search bar is gone, but the location bar will search by default if you enter keywords instead of a URL -- I'm not sure if I like it or not, but I can live with it.

They did bump up the minimum tab width, though. It looks a lot cooler when you have to scroll tabs, which is good, because that happens MUCH more often.

The desktop-effects stuff seems a lot more polished now, and a lot faster, but if I just wanted desktop-effects, I'd use Vista -- or Compiz.

And across the board, basic functionality is completely bastardized. What's more frustrating is that kde4 has done some things so much better than kde3 -- Kate and Okular stand out (Okular being the new name for KPDF). And it does feel faster.

But in MANY places, what used to be a solid dozen options in a dialog, or even several tabbed dialogs, is now a tiny dialog of maybe two useless options.

Oh, and backwards compatibility is shot to hell. Amarok isn't KDE4 yet, and its global shortcuts don't work. For that matter, for some reason, it's decided that the Windows/Super key shall never work in custom keyboard shortcuts -- it appears as some strange Unicode thing.

All around, I'm thinking I'll use KDE3 as long as I can, or start scripting wmii -- but I suspect it'll be KDE5 by the time they fix it. I love the KDE4 tech, and some of the concepts (Plasma), but not until I can get back all the toys I had in KDE3.

That, and Kubuntu seems to be putting a lot more polish on KDE3 than on their "KDE4 remix". Though maybe not all of that is their fault -- try shrinking the panel to "tiny", which is available. The K menu icon now wraps around to the top of the screen. WTF?

blackbelt_jones said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Benji said...

I don't know what happened to KDE's mentality. It seems like Gnome was always the "let's dumb things down" desktop.
Now KDE4 are getting rid of the features that the power-users craved and experimenting in philoshpical UI concepts. The whole KDE4 experience is like using an early beta project that still feels years away from being completed.
I've gone to gnome (grudgingly) now, if nothing else for the fact that I can't really understand the design path the kde devs are heading down anymore. They've pretty much alienated me and a large amount of their user base with their lofty ambitions.

Tristan Grimaux said...

I fill the same as Bengi, and we are on version 4.1, where the search bar is gone in konqueror and all i get when I try to enter the keywords in the url is "unknown protocol".

I am really disappointed, and all the reviews I see on KDE are made by people using Gnome. And I hate Gnome so much when I am the user, it's so freaking dumb I really can't cope with it.

And now KDE is following the same path. It's driving me crazy.

insane coder said...

I have to say KDE 4.1 is much better, and coming back to where KDE should be. Although it's not there yet. I have high hopes for KDE4 if the devs don't get sucked into the GNOME black hole of features.

Hopefully I'll have an updated review out of KDE 4.1 in the future.

mahasamoot said...

"They've pretty much alienated me and a large amount of their user base with their lofty ambitions."

I'm also very alienated, especially with the Kubuntu crew for dropping 3.5 while 4.x is still beta rubbish. They claim that they can't do both, but they've been doing both for over a year already... wtfo?

KDE 4.1 is a bit better, but it's still got a long way to go. It remains to be seen whether 4.2 will be usable... the more they push this on us, the more they're going to alienate us. We're not resisting out of a fear of change, we're resisting because it's beta rubbish that's not ready yet.

The KDE crew made a huge mistake in calling a Tech-Preview "4.0" KDE 4.1 is still not ready to be called a beta, but it's the only shipping version of KDE on Kubuntu 8.10... thus the KDE community is compounding their mistakes, rather than learning from them.

Adam said...

I know this post is a bit old, but people are evidently still reading it. I just thought I'd say that I like KDE 4.

The Up button being in the file dialog is a good thing for when you are in line edit mode. Making the button disappear would be ugly and inconsistent.

The Trash being in the Places sidebar is consistent with everywhere else. Taking it out in certain places would only serve to cause confusion, I think.

There is no Up button on the Dolphin toolbar, but it's in the Go menu, and you can add it to the toolbar manually. Again, making the toolbar change depending on the whether you're in line edit or location navigation mode would not be ideal. Also, I would rather not have both modes active, as I think that's a waste of screen space.

felix said...

Krusader

sabee said...

Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing.
AWS Training in Chennai |Best Amazon Web Services Training in Chennai
AWS Training in Rajaji Nagar | Amazon Web Services Training in Rajaji Nagar

Best AWS Training Institute in BTM Layout Bangalore ,AWS Coursesin BTM

chitra pragya said...

Really nice experience you have. Thank you for sharing. It will surely be an experience to someone.
angularjs Training in bangalore

angularjs Training in btm

angularjs Training in electronic-city

angularjs Training in online

angularjs Training in marathahalli

sai said...

Woah this blog is wonderful i like studying your posts. Keep up the great work! You understand, lots of persons are hunting around for this info, you could help them greatly.
Python training in marathahalli | Python training institute in pune

sudhagar raja said...

I know you feel more happy when you get things done and best of all those things are your most precious treasure.
Java training in Chennai | Java training in Bangalore

Java online training | Java training in Pune

Ram priya said...

Well you use a hard way for publishing, you could find much easier one!
Data Science Training in Chennai | Data Science training in anna nagar

Data Science training in chennai | Data science training in Bangalore

Data Science training in marathahalli | Data Science training in btm layout


vijay antony said...

Wow it is really wonderful and awesome thus it is very much useful for me to understand many concepts and helped me a lot. it is really explainable very well and i got more information from your blog.

rpa interview questions and answers
automation anywhere interview questions and answers
blueprism interview questions and answers
uipath interview questions and answers
rpa training in chennai

MyTraining said...

Great Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good,

AWS Training in Bangalore

Best AWS Training Institute in Bangalore

sasitamil said...

Resources like the one you mentioned here will be very useful to me ! I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful


devops online training

aws online training

data science with python online training

data science online training

rpa online training

sai said...

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us
Microsoft Azure online training
Selenium online training
Java online training
Python online training
uipath online training

istiaq ahmed said...

Language is the primary way to strengthen your roots and preserve the culture, heritage, and identity. Tamil is the oldest, the ancient language in the world with a rich literature. Aaranju.com is a self-learning platform to learn Tamil very easy and effective way.
Aaranju.com is a well-structured, elementary school curriculum from Kindergarten to Grade 5. Students will be awarded the grade equivalency certificate after passing the exams. Very engaging and fun learning experience.
Now you can learn Tamil from your home or anywhere in the world.

You can knows more:

Learn Tamil thru English

Tamil School online

Easy way to learn Tamil

Learn Tamil from Home

Facebook

YouTube

twitter

ravi kumar said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

Birth certificate in delhi
Birth certificate in ghaziabad
Birth certificate in gurgaon
Birth certificate in noida
How to get birth certificate in ghaziabad
how to get birth certificate in delhi
birth certificate agent in delhi
how to download birth certificate
birth certificate in greater noida
birth certificate agent in delhi
Birth certificate delhi

Techy said...

Nice Post
For Data Science training in Bangalore, Visit:
Data Science training in Bangalore

Suji Sanjana said...

CCNA training in chennai
Ethical Hacking training in chennai
Matlab training in chennai
C++ training in chennai
Cloud computing training in chennai
R programming training in chennai

Adam Thomas said...

Thanks for giving these excellent information, you have a very good post. Such a lovely posting.
Assignment Writing Service
Online Assignment Help

rickypauls said...

Assignment Help is the best solution to fix the issues of assignment writing at affordable rates. Get your homework completed in one click. For more information, talk to our experts.

Rajesh said...

Nice infromation
Selenium Training In Chennai
Selenium course in chennai
Selenium Training
Selenium Training institute In Chennai
Best Selenium Training in chennai
Selenium Training In Chennai

Rajesh said...

Rpa Training in Chennai
Rpa Course in Chennai
Rpa training institute in Chennai
Best Rpa Course in Chennai
uipath Training in Chennai
Blue prism training in Chennai

Rajesh said...

Data Science Training In Chennai
Data Science Course In Chennai
Data Science Training institute In Chennai
Best Data Science Training In Chennai

Rajesh said...

Nice infromation
Selenium Training In Chennai
Selenium course in chennai
Selenium Training
Selenium Training institute In Chennai
Best Selenium Training in chennai
Selenium Training In Chennai

hpprintercare said...

In fact, interacting with HP customer service team is obvious as you face some blunder with Hp devices. Contact to HP customer service team is obvious to take away from failure. You do not forget to reach on the way how do I contact HP customer service. No matter what communication modes used are, the complaint query has been put on top tier position. Well, the best way to approach our expert with prompt connects with phone number. For getting the soon solution over failure, you must dial toll free number. Feel free to contact our expert

Outlookhelp said...

Awesome article! Are you looking for help related to outlook? As a Outlook Support member, We are reachable 24x7 to help out needy customers like you.
Is there a phone number for Outlook support?
How Do I Contact Microsoft Outlook Support
How do I call Outlook support?
Outlook Support Phone Number
Microsoft Outlook Support

Canon Support said...

Canon has made its presence in the international market for offering excellent quality printers, both for household as well as official use. Most of the new models of Canon Printer are built with the Wi-Fi compatibility. By using these Canon printers in your working premises, you can print outstanding quality documents from a computing device or even a Smartphone by just giving a command. In this, you don’t even need to set up any wired connection to connect your canon printer with computer. You must have the proper knowledge to Connect Canon Printer To Wi-Fi. The steps are very simple and you can get them by dialing given helpline number and taking assistance from ingenious professionals.

HP Printer Troubleshooting said...

If you are an HP device user and having any query and technical issue with the product then go to www.hp.com to get immediate help. Your query will be resolved by a team of experts in minimum time.

Email Tech Support said...

Does your HP printer is not working accordingly? Is it flinging unanticipated errors and all of a sudden goes offline? If your answer is yes, then the very first step you should take is to upgrade your HP printer driver from a trustworthy source. And if we are discussing about downloading HP driver then only 123.hp.com.setup is dependable that is easily available in the market. Just open this site, provide the printer’s model number or name and then hit the search button. After that you have to select your printer and then you will be head towards the downloading link of your upgraded software for HP printer.

jone smith said...

If you find the spare part of your bike visite on automartz and get up 70% off bike and cars spare parts and you can also bike accessories here like helmet, visor, cleane etc. car and bike spare parts

hpprintercare said...

Is there any problem in your HP printer regardless of mode? In case your answer is yes, then you must have to think about this key fact how to deal this problem shortly. Most probable case is that your HP printer comes across with offline issues. Availing in this failure you cannot get the authority to take the full length printout. why does my hp printer keeps going offline? It is typical instance which does not allow finding the premium quality output. We know this key fact that any problem is not so hard whose solution is out of control from general persons. We do not like this thing that any person faces any difficulty in this business output as they are devoted their mind to take the high class output. As soon as you trap in these failure sets for a long time, you must take the short association of our team. Feel free to connect our team

John Miller said...

The Assignment Help services are the best way to get all the work done on time. The service truly made my life as a student so easy.

Online Assignment Help
Online Assignment Help Services
Assignment Help Online

rickypauls said...

Using Assignment Help Online services, students can complete their assignment on time. Students who have no ideas how to start their papers, they can search for greatassignmenthelp.com to compose their documents.

jones said...

Do you want to take help from technicians for setting up brother printer wireless? If yes, we can guide you for Brother Wireless printer Setup in the right ways. We work independently as a third party tech support service provider, offering online technical steps for setting up brother printer in the right ways. Our printer experts are technically proficient for setting up brother wireless printer in the easy ways.

james said...

Are you facing some interruption in brother printer with the limelight of error code? Well, underlying of error code 2147500037 disturbs a customer a lot and they cannot take decision what to do or not. Feel free to contact our expert.

Brother Printer Support said...

You can now use your printer for multiple purposes. In case you encounter any problem related to the printer you have, please get in touch with Brother Printer Support Number.

Internet Providers For my Address said...

Compare the plans and choose the best internet providers in New Jersey.

Tech Support said...


Geek Squad Tech Support provides the best technical help and guidance. Get in touch with extensively trained tech support team for all sort of queries and issues regarding your devices. You can contact Geek Squad round the clock according to your convenience.

Tech Support said...

Geek Squad Online Support is a technical group of experts available online to resolve your issues. The experts at this helpline are great at solving your issues, instantly. Call the Geek Squad Online Support experts to avail the best services.

Tech Support said...

Get the solutions to all the technical issues with all your electronic appliances at Geek Squad Tech Support. Avail wide no of services, on-site, and over the Internet via remote access and In-store, and also provides 24/7 telephone and emergency on-site support. Reach the experts at Geek Squad Support for removing all technical glitches with your devices

hpprintercare said...

WPS stands for Wi-Fi Protected Setup and this application is being used for making connection between your router and wireless HP printer device. To establish a connection wirelessly, you have to find wps pin on HP printer and then make it in use. You may think that how can I find WPS pin, so my friend just be relaxed as it is very easy to get the pin. First thing you need to do is to go to the control panel of your HP Printer and then press the Wireless button. Move to the Settings option. After touching on the WiFi Protected Setup, you need to follow the prompts appearing on the screen. You will be driven to PIN, tap on this PIN. Doing this, WPS PIN will be displayed on the screen.Use such pin to establish a connection between your computer and HP printer wirelessly. For any further query, call on toll-free number

Online Technical Help said...

Amazing Post, Thank you for sharing this post really this is awesome and very useful. Well if you get time you must read more on
Microsoft Office 365 Support
Outlook Support Phone Number
Microsoft Support Phone Number
Is There A Phone Number For Outlook Support?
Is there a Phone Number for Office 365 Support?
Is there a Phone Number for Microsoft Support?
Is there a Phone Number for Microsoft Office Support?
How do I contact Hotmail support?