Saturday, April 9, 2016

OAuth - Why it doesn't work, and how to Zero-day attack existing services

Since this article is extremely long, it is also available in a PDF version. This article also has a companion website.


What is OAuth?

Let me begin with a quick run down on what we're discussing. OAuth is a family of proposals that is being used for designing different kinds of authorization and authentication systems, and framing the usage for APIs and how different systems are integrated.

OAuth exists in many flavors, version 1, 1a, 2, and other specifications based on top of parts of it. Its exact usage also greatly differs across the many different implementations out there.


I've written about OAuth in the past, and I've gotten a lot of feedback from readers all over. To avoid some criticism my past article received, I'd like to point out that this article will be focusing on how OAuth is typically used, and most of the points discussed here are true of nearly every major service which leverages OAuth in some way.

To put this differently, not every platform utilizing OAuth is necessarily broken. Due to the various flavors of OAuth, and the 76-page document on different possibilities with OAuth 2.0, it is possible to create something secure and sane to use which conforms to something OAuth based. Therefore your favorite flavor and design with OAuth may escape some or all of the problems discussed herein, even though the odds are that it does not.

Some of you may also argue that some things done with OAuth are misusing the specifications, or that OAuth doesn't specifically mandate things be done the way they are. Whatever the case may be, I'm not here to write about a particular OAuth based specification, but how OAuth is currently utilized by major players in the market, regardless if what these organizations are doing conforms with the specifications or not. This will impact many readers, either because they use services making use of OAuth in these ways, or they're maintaining OAuth-based services, and are building platforms similarly to how many others are building them.

Article structure

This article is going to be a long one, and in fact most sections in this article cover topics with enough material to make an entire article themselves, so let me give a brief outline on what this article is about and how it will be organized.

This article is the presentation of the culmination of research into what is currently being done in the market with OAuth. Not everything in this article is consistent with every product making use of OAuth, but this article will present what was found to be common practice and the biggest culprits behind insecure or useless services.

After this introduction, I'm going to begin by analyzing security flaws with OAuth. The general principles behind some of these flaws are well known by those in the security community, and already briefly analyzed in existing publications. However, I'm going to be covering some cases that have not yet been publicized, and also elaborating upon some points of well known flaws to make them easier to understand to the average developer or manager and emphasize why they need to be concerned.

After that I'm going to present an analysis of how some key components of OAuth are popularly implemented and how the popular implementations cripple services which choose to use OAuth by severely, inappropriately, and undesirably limiting what can be accomplished with them. Some techniques will be discussed that can be used as the basis for workarounds in a limited amount of cases, with a focus on the absurdity involved in implementing such. As part of the above, it will be frequently pointed out how those using OAuth are hurting themselves and their business.

Lastly I will briefly cover a few cases for when and how OAuth can be used properly, along with viable alternatives to OAuth which are currently in use. I will provide a survey of alternative techniques that will include what serious companies like Amazon and others are doing to achieve secure, usable, and reliable APIs.

Responsible Disclosure

Several of the flaws with OAuth as is it popularly used today can be exploited to carry out strong attacks against major services. Attacks against OAuth are nothing new, as IBM, Oracle, and other concerned members of the IETF issued a 71-page document describing 50 classes of attacks against OAuth based services over three years ago, and I already discussed some of these points in my previous article. Despite this though, major security flaws with OAuth-based systems are extremely common.

I've spoken to executives and developers at several major corporations to point out security flaws with their OAuth-based systems (in one case, 4 years ago), and not one of them has done anything to fix their systems. It seems as though, given the popularity of OAuth, they haven’t heard of any of the alternative viable solutions, and they therefore assume that OAuth must be the most secure thing available. It also seems as if they either have not heard or shrug off the information documenting the demonstrated attacks against the core principals of OAuth. I'm hoping that wider public dissemination of this information will give those affected the proper kick in the pants that they need, and serve as a wake up call to those designing or maintaining services.

Therefore, if you investigate and find that some or all of these flaws exist in your service which either provides or makes use of something OAuth-based, please act responsibly in dealing with this information. Update your services appropriately, or apply appropriate pressure to your business partners to address the relevant issues.

Although the various information mentioned here and linked to from here can be used to exploit existing services today, please be responsible and aim to improve and not destroy what belongs to others. This article is meant as a wake up call for those implementing their services improperly and an appeal to improve them, not a how-to guide for hackers looking to exploit them.

Usage Scenarios

For this article, I'm going to focus on two usage scenarios and see how OAuth stacks up with them and why it doesn't work. It is important to keep these scenarios in mind, as I will be constantly returning to them throughout this article.

Let us imagine an Exciting Video Service (or EVS), where users can upload videos and share those videos with their friends, providing either public or restricted access to their uploads. EVS also provides OAuth-based APIs for uploading and deleting videos, and managing permissions regarding who can view those videos.

While I will be focusing on this imaginary service for sake of example, the issues under discussion will apply to any service, whether it's for file and document storage, calendar management, online meetings, discussion groups, resource management, or anything else that provides an OAuth-based API. Also bear in mind that I'm not actually referring to any specific video service, even though some or all of these issues may apply to existing video services which make use of OAuth. It can be left as an exercise for the reader to determine which ones.

For our first usage scenario, let us imagine a camcorder manufacturer that would like to supply software with their camcorder which, among other things, allows videos recorded with the device to be uploaded to EVS. It is intended to allow users of this camcorder to plug their device into their computer, open the custom software, select the videos on the device they'd like to upload, and come back later knowing that all the selected videos will have been uploaded to EVS.

For our second scenario, let us imagine a small organization decides to purchase 50 accounts with EVS for their employees, so all employees can upload videos and have them shared with other employees from the same department. This organization is using A Friendly Custom Platform, for managing their employees and which sub-units they belong to, and would like to integrate their AFCP service with EVS. This organization will expect that when a manager assigns someone to the sales department using AFCP that the employee in question will automatically gain access to all videos that belong to members of the sales department. They will expect the reverse to occur if they remove someone from the sales department, and all similar scenarios.

The Issues

Security Related

Stealing credentials / Gaining elevated access

One of the most popular reasons why token-based authentication systems (a core premise of OAuth) are currently used is that when implemented properly they avoid the need to provide third party applications and services with individual users’ credentials. It is undesirable to provide third parties with personal user credentials, because:
  • It gives third parties more access than they require.
  • It is another place personal credentials are stored and can be stolen from.
  • It requires that API consumers be updated when users change their credentials.
  • Access cannot be easily revoked from just one application without also revoking access from all other applications.
  • User credentials can be too limited where additional authentication factors are in use.
The above list of problems can be avoided by any token-based authentication system, not just OAuth. While this is counted as a strength to OAuth, it is hardly unique, and viable alternatives can be used which carry the same strengths without OAuth’s weaknesses.

However, despite being based on a solid premise, OAuth as popularly implemented attempts to avoid the above problems by providing a system with something along the lines of the following steps:
  1. Users visit the third party application/service such as AFCP and informs it of their desire to integrate a particular service.
  2. AFCP then brings up a special login page hosted by EVS where the user enters their EVS credentials.
  3. EVS then asks the user to confirm they are sure they want the third party application/service, AFCP, to have all the levels of access specified.
  4. EVS then provides AFCP with some kind of token or series of tokens it can then use to make the various API calls.
Since these tokens are not the user's credentials, and can be specific to every user and application combination, limited in their permissions, and later revoked, it seemingly avoids all the aforementioned problems this setup was designed to address. However, in reality, despite having a sound premise at its core, this particular usage flow used by popular implementations of OAuth does not address all the above enumerated issues.

This design begins from an insecure standpoint. The rule of thumb when it comes to designing a secure platform is that anything which begins from an insecure standpoint is already lost, it cannot be salvaged. Thanks to step #1, which begins on a service making use of EVS rather than EVS itself, users have already been man-in-the-middled from the very beginning. This is the computer-system equivalent of giving out personal or financial information over the phone to an incoming caller who claims to be from some utility service you use but whose number you either do not recognize or is blocked. There have been many such scams in recent times, and don’t need to be elaborated upon here. The main point is that if you cannot trust the party which initiated a connection, then you cannot trust the connection at all. It is impossible to design a secure authentication system for API use which achieves the objectives enumerated above unless the first step begins from the EVS side itself.

Similar to the phone scam example, where the caller simply needs to sound as if they are calling from the company they’re impersonating, to attack a user, a third-party application or service just has to provide something which looks like the special EVS login page for step #2. Most users will not be aware that the page displaying the EVS logo and asking for their username and password is not authentically from EVS. Once a third-party service gains the user’s credentials in this manner, the application or service, and those behind it, now have more access than they should, and their access cannot be revoked without the user changing their credentials.

Since users have already been conditioned with OAuth-based login flows with all kinds of embedded frames with corporate logos, silly pop-ups, and redirects with ridiculous URLs on atypical domains, most users won’t even notice any red flags which would alert them that the page into which they’re currently entering their credentials may not be genuine. A colleague of mine put it so: The companies themselves are training their users to be phishing targets. If URLs are needed to be displayed, the attacker can even register an official sounding domain (,,,, and can even have redirection go through some URL which appears to be legit.

In the case of actual standalone applications, such as that provided with your camcorder, nothing outrageous even needs to be done. Since the web browser is being provided by a custom application, it can already capture every single input box and all data sent over the network with it, it doesn't even need to spoof some login form.

This class of attack is labeled in the aforementioned security document as 4.1.4. Threat: End-User Credentials Phished Using Compromised or Embedded Browser. The solutions offered? (emphasis mine)
Client applications should avoid directly asking users for their credentials. In addition, end users could be educated about phishing attacks and best practices, such as only accessing trusted clients, as OAuth does not provide any protection against malicious applications and the end user is solely responsible for the trustworthiness of any native application installed.
Client developers should not write client applications that collect authentication information directly from users and should instead delegate this task to a trusted system component, e.g., the system browser.
Essentially OAuth security guidelines say that developers making use of OAuth should not try to attack the users or do anything malicious. Relying on external developers not to do anything malicious is not a security model any sane service designer would rely on.

Nearly every major OAuth-based service I know of can be attacked with the method outlined here.

For those of you thinking OAuth is the new gold-standard for security, wake up! OAuth as popularly implemented is already defeated before it has begun. Many systems implemented way before OAuth ever existed are secure and work around this issue effectively. Unfortunately, and all too often, I’ve seen services transition themselves from something secure to an insecure OAuth model because someone told their developers or managers that OAuth was “more secure”, “forward thinking”, “future proof”, or any number of other buzzwords which sound nice but lack anything in the way of substance. Most of the time these changes are implemented without even reviewing whether these changes address any existing problems or if the solution is any better than what they are replacing.

Masquerading as an OAuth-using service

A common mistake I see in OAuth-based service design is the supplying of an endpoint designed for a web browser which accepts as one of its parameters a client_secret (or something of the same concept). The OAuth client_id and client_secret parameters are essentially a third-party platform’s equivalent of its own personal API username and password, and should therefore only be known to those developers making use of EVS's APIs. Since it is analogous to a password, the client_secret parameter should never be sent across a user’s web browser (hint: the word secret is in the name of the parameter). If some user of an application or service can find out the client_id and client_secret of the application or service, that means they can masquerade as that service and potentially do something malicious. Also note that some services will sometimes name the client_secret parameter something else, so review the service you are working with carefully and see if any of their other parameters need to be kept secret. Unfortunately, since important variables are sometimes not indicative of their nature, this problem is more common than it should be. Additionally, some services will build an authentication flow on top of OAuth using the client_id alone. Be wary of these, because under certain circumstances such a client_id functions exactly like a client_secret.

Since OAuth as popularly implemented transfers users between multiple websites using a web browser, and that OAuth needs one website to send the other a client_id and client_secret (or equivalent), such as between AFCP and EVS, these are actually available to the user of the web browser if they monitor the browser's HTTP log. This is even possible in various custom browsers built into applications where a simple right click allows access to an inspector of some sort with network logging capabilities.

In our case of AFCP utilizing EVS, this flaw would allow employees which have some access to AFCP to potentially gain more access than they should, and perhaps apply permissions they should not have access to. In a different example, if Facebook made use of an OAuth endpoint via a web browser for GMail where both the client_id and client_secret were transferred through the web browser, this would allow every user of Facebook to impersonate Facebook itself in this regard.

This issue is present any time an OAuth endpoint expects to be sent the client_secret in plain text via a user’s web browser, or the API consumer is mislead into thinking doing so is a requirement and embeds a secret where they should not. A good indication that this vulnerability may be present is an endpoint where both the parameters for client_secret (or equivalent) and redirect_uri are expected (or even optionally allowed). The redirect_uri parameter is designed specifically for browser use to indicate to EVS where to send the user's browser after the login actions have been performed on the EVS side. As such, it means that if redirect_uri is in use for transferring on an endpoint, the flow is expected to be performed via the user’s web browser. Neither of the major OAuth documents specify or call for the use of such a case where both the parameters for client_secret and redirect_uri are expected to be used like this.

A quick search online of such potentially offending OAuth-based APIs unfortunately shows many hits. Although Google offers many ways to use OAuth, they have a flow which advertises the two being used together:

 Citrix makes this mistake:

Along with Cisco:

So does Github:

And Salesforce:

As well as Buffer:

And Zendesk:

And the popular Disqus:

I got this list after searching with Google for only two minutes. I'm sure readers can find many more with a little more effort. Note, the above list is not an indication that any of these services are directly vulnerable or that it's too easy to misuse them. Due to various factors, where for example, Zendesk specifically says their redirect_uri parameter is not actually used for redirection in this particular case, and that they even show that the endpoint should be called from an application using curl - not a full fledged web browser, developers will hopefully not be misled into trying to do something dangerous with it. However, inexperienced developers in their applications may try to load one of these endpoints with a custom web browser. Furthermore, this combination simply being common in the wild is lowering developer's defenses against a potentially nasty misuse, where even the more experienced developers of OAuth-based services are blindly applying in similar situations, especially where the client_secret is named something else and the idea of keeping a secret is lost on them.

A good indication that a service is broken in this regard is when several popular OAuth libraries fail to work with this service. Such services will generally offer their own "SDK" which will work with them, and point third party developers to the official SDK if they complain their favorite library is unable to make use of their frankenstein-OAuth. These kinds of customizations often goes unnoticed, as the majority of developers prefer to make use of an advertised SDK when provided, and forgo rolling their own combination of software to utilize a service.

This class of attack is labeled in the aforementioned security document as 4.1.1. Threat: Obtaining Client Secrets. However, it doesn't even mention the specific attack case where a server is requiring use of a web browser for passing both the client_id and client_secret (or something of similar use). The authors of the document probably didn't expect anyone to design a service which could be this stupid nor developers using such APIs to make use of them with a custom web browser or SDK. These developers are mixing and matching separate components from different parts of the OAuth specifications in unspecified ways and expecting their platforms to remain secure without considering what new issues may be introduced by this patchwork approach. This is unfortunately the manner in which most of the OAuth players today function, and the already rampant problem only perpetuates itself as more and more providers jump on the bandwagon and copy the approaches they see or think they see being used by others.

Odds are you'll be able to find many systems making use of the above services which are exploitable due to this problem. It's especially common in desktop applications, where a secret can be directly pulled out of a compiled application binary, even if the service being used isn't requiring anything insecure. It is important to note that Google offers many ways to use OAuth, and only one of them has an endpoint which receives both client_secret and redirect_uri. In the case of Google at least, they aren't recommending this endpoint for web browser based applications despite the presence of redirect_uri, but I'm sure that doesn't stop anybody from using it with a custom web browser or copying this flow into their service for an endpoint intended for regular browser use. In addition, Google appears to be the exception which proves the rule, and there's still the stupidity of all the other OAuth-based services out there which do not allow for secure OAuth-flows in such cases, as they require the client_secret (or equivalent) to always be passed, even when the flow is via a web browser. Worse, many of these services can only be used via a user’s web browser, a point which will be further elaborated upon below.

The aforementioned security document mentions a couple of malicious things one can do once they steal an application's credentials (client_id and client_secret). I'll cover some issues below that can be coupled with this attack to allow one to do some nasty things which have not, to my knowledge, been previously covered. I'm sure my creative readers will also find additional ways to exploit stealing what is supposed to be kept secret.

Insecure Tokens

Token based authentication is a new concept to many developers. Therefore, it is also commonly misunderstood. Many developers designing something like EVS think if they simply follow some design guidelines (such as OAuth) on how APIs should work, or copy what other platforms are doing, then their platform is inherently secure. However, in order for something to be secure, it requires that every single component be secure, that the combination of the components be secure, and that the overall framework be secure. Remember, security is only as strong as its weakest link, and it is not enough to rely solely upon adhering to some overall framework and assume that any and all use of it is therefore secure. The OAuth-based framework in and of itself provides very little in the way of ensuring the security of the underlying components (if it's not outright counter-secure for certain components).

In order for a token-based system to have any semblance of security, the tokens generated must use a cryptographically secure pseudo-random number generator, a topic which is not so well understood. Even worse, APIs for good CSPRNGs in popular scripting languages is severely lacking, yet such scripting languages are often the foundation of what is being used to design many popular modern services.

If the tokens generated are predictable, that means that an attacker can impersonate users and perform malicious activities with their account simply by guessing at what a token might be. I saw one OAuth-based service from a major fortune 500 company which just uses some constantly incrementing ID (perhaps a database field?) for its tokens. I found another where I noticed the tokens generated all seemed to be the output of some monotonic-function. With further research, I found it was an extremely simple algorithm based on the current real world time. On these systems, I could log in as myself, see what the current token IDs are, predict what the next series are going to be, and then use that as part of a token exchange or other operation on behalf of the next random user. Combined with other techniques, even more targeted attacks can be accomplished.

This class of attack is labeled in the aforementioned security document as 4.5.3. Threat: Obtaining Refresh Token by Online Guessing and 4.6.3. Threat: Guessing Access Tokens. While this issue is remediable, the amount of services currently making this mistake, and the ease with which this mistake is made, does not bode well for proving the security of a given OAuth-based service from an external review.

Certain attacks against randomness, which is a whole other topic, can be used to utterly destroy an OAuth-based server if a security-hardened CSPRNG is not in use. While such issues are extremely problematic with other systems too, the issues are much more pronounced with popular OAuth implementations whose entire method of functioning is based around the concept of handing out random numbers. These tokens are generated server-side by EVS, and when used constantly as OAuth as popularly implemented does, drains the reliability of the server and increases predictability of all tokens involved. If you don't have a security-hardened CSPRNG for your environment which can protect against modern attacks, you're probably better off with another protocol which is more forgiving in this regard.

It should however be noted that some OAuth-based implementations structure things in such a way to move randomness requirements to the client-side. While in many ways this is just moving a problem elsewhere, it does reduce the attacks surface from the service-side of things. This at least allows for more educated consumers of OAuth-based services to use a service they can trust in a secure manner, even if the less educated consumers may still be vulnerable. Applying this to our example, this setup would mean that the developers of AFCP can ensure its use of EVS is secure, and can't be exposed to such threats from EVS itself, even if ABC or XYZ do not use EVS securely.

Cross-site request forgeries

Before I get more into this one, let me just point out that despite the name, CSRF attacks are not necessarily originated from a third party site. CSRF attacks can also be initiated from within sites themselves that allow users to post their own links, such as various online discussion and messaging software.

There are many different techniques and frameworks designed to combat CSRF in various ways. OAuth-based integration can make many of these systems unusable or prompt various unsafe practices which can open sites up to attack.

One defense mechanism against CSRF is to ensure that the referer (sic) sent by the browser does not point to an external site. Since many OAuth implementations require that users are directed to certain pages from an external site, this defense cannot be enforced. Since the full scope of what pages and multitude of third party domains an OAuth server will perform redirection through, and since these URLs and domains involved are undocumented and may see periodic changes, the full scope of EVS domains and pages cannot be whitelisted.

Also one needs to consider whether it’s possible for those offering EVS to turn around and try to attack AFCP. One of the principles behind OAuth is that OAuth-based services are not expected to trust their consumers, yet at the same time, require that the consumers fully trust them by allowing them blanket CSRF avoidance. An ideal authentication system would ensure a mutual level of distrust, not a one-way street.

Partial whitelisting for either sources or destinations may also prove problematic. Depending on the anti-CSRF framework in use, tools for disabling certain features may be all-or-nothing, and it may not be possible to disable features on specific pages or for specific sources, forcing those who make use of EVS to stop using their anti-CSRF framework altogether.

OAuth specifically defines the optional state parameter to be used to specify CSRF tokens to prevent CSRF attacks. However, I found that OAuth-based services commonly have limitations on length or allowed characters in state, and may not return it verbatim as required. Therefore, due to weird compatibility issues, many consumers of OAuth-based services find themselves forced to turn off CSRF protection altogether on redirection endpoints. This is labeled under 10.14. Code Injection and Input Validation. Another consideration with the state parameter is that anyone with access to it on the EVS side can alter the request before sending the browser back to AFCP with an otherwise valid state parameter.

OAuth-based API consumers are further limited by being required to define a URI or series of URIs up-front upon registration of their application or service, which is a white-list of URIs that can be used for redirect_uri. Putting aside for the moment major usability issues with such a system which will be discussed below, this limitation forces developers to start getting creative with the state parameter or other potentially dangerous ideas which can lead to a whole slew of issues. Many OAuth-based servers allow only a single white-listed URI, or require an exact match with redirect_uri and disallow additional parameters appended to it. This causes developers to stop using their anti-CSRF framework and start trying to shove all sorts of dangerous stuff into the state parameter or create other poorly thought out systems. The end result is some combination of redirect_uri and state that can be used to push users to some page they should not be pushed to. This is labeled under 10.15. Open Redirectors.

The problem with such redirection can potentially be exploited by itself, due to the combination of parameters not being fully authenticated, or this exploit can be combined with the issue - Masquerading as an OAuth-using service documented above which can be used to wreak havoc upon users. By making use of a stolen client_id and client_secret, a malicious party can create a redirection flow which appears genuine even to AFCP, by the fact that the authentication was performed with AFCP’s own credentials. A malicious user of AFCP may also be able to find a way to use or modify the state parameter, perhaps with stolen client credentials, in order to gain permissions they should not have within AFCP. All in all, due to poor design by OAuth as popularly implemented, and the difficulties external developers face with poor education on certain topics, attacking OAuth-based consumers is often much easier than it should be.

Important reading here is also 3.5. Redirect URI, 3.6. "state" Parameter, and Threat: CSRF Attack against redirect-uri.

Section conclusion

In terms of security, OAuth as popularly implemented does quite poorly. OAuth fails to achieve many of the security objectives it supposedly sets out to achieve. Further, some OAuth-based services outright require that their consumers open themselves up to various attacks in order to use them. Even in cases where OAuth-based services can be used securely, which isn't always known (due to important service-side security details such as token generation methods being undocumented and closed source), OAuth still leads to many poor programming practices. OAuth does little to protect external developers, and various frameworks that such developers use in turn don't provide real security or can't be used securely without strict discipline and caution.

This article in turn only covers some issues that I found rampant. Some of these issues are also the result of developers copying extremely poor practices they see others using alongside OAuth, practices which aren't even mandated by any OAuth specification.

Developers for both OAuth-based services and the consumers thereof need to read and understand all of the linked documentation for implementing and using OAuth-based platforms. One also needs to fully comprehend the 50 classes of attacks listed, the multitude of attacks in each class, and note that the implementation material and security guidelines are not exhaustive. It should also be noted that this article only touches the surface of OAuth security problems, even if it does cover some issues not documented in the official material. Compounded with this, any changes made to the official OAuth proposals introduce a whole new set of security challenges, and these kinds of changes are unfortunately common. One in turn also needs to understand other security-related fields such as random number generation and security verification techniques to achieve any reasonable level of security with OAuth.

If you're looking for real security, I recommend you look elsewhere. I'll cover some alternatives to OAuth in the final section.

Usability Related

Pull the plug architecture

OAuth as popularly implemented, requires that every integration done with an OAuth-based service require a set of application specific credentials to simply exist. These credentials aren't actually used to manage any particular set of user or organization accounts.

This design allows EVS at any time to pull the plug (revoke the application credentials) on any application they no longer wish to service. This is often seen as an advantage to OAuth. However, this exact design is also telling of the intentions behind EVS's service, namely that they want full control over all use of EVS, and have the right to refuse service via APIs on a whim.

If the company behind EVS decides to go into their own camcorder business, and wants to reduce competition, they can pull the plug on competing products that integrate with EVS. Imagine if desktop applications from their inception required approval from the Operating System vendor in order to function. When Microsoft decided to create Excel, they could have pulled the plug on Lotus 1-2-3. Nowadays they would be able to just prevent anyone from using Open Office or Libre Office, and force everyone who wants some desktop application office suite to purchase Microsoft Office.

Besides being an evil way to practice business, this also hurts adoption of the service itself. Why would camcorder vendors want to waste money developing for EVS if any application they design can be shut down on a whim remotely? Even if they did offer some application with EVS compatibility, they certainly wouldn't want to advertise it for fear of being sued for false advertising and premature termination of service if EVS ever pulls the plug on them. Would you be comfortable providing a service subscription to someone, knowing that some third-party could come and completely disable the service at any time? Would you really expect that a client (especially a paying client) would accept an apology that says “sorry, EVS shut our service down, there’s nothing we can do”? Do you really think that such clients would let it go without seeking refunds and damages from you?

As a manager making buying decisions and choosing a video hosting solution to purchase and integrate with AFCP, why would they choose EVS over other vendors, when EVS can quit working for their use-case at any time? When a vendor offers some service which does not use OAuth, they typically include some sort of API guarantee. Meaning their contract or terms of service include API usage specifically for the service package being purchased, and the package itself guarantees access to APIs. OAuth-based services, on the other hand, only guarantee access to the service directly, and tell prospective clients to review their OAuth APIs and apply for a completely separate set of developer access accounts if they wish to have API access. Due to this, the intelligent and discerning buyer will choose the non-OAuth-based service over an OAuth-based one every single time.

A malicious user can also make use of the security issue above - Masquerading as an OAuth-using service, to acquire application specific credentials to impersonate it and do something which violates the terms of service for the APIs in question. This way attackers can ensure your application gets its plug pulled. In the case of our example, a competing camcorder vendor need only to obtain one copy of the camcorder to EVS application, extract the client_id and client_secret from the software, and then they can ensure that their competition fails.

Incorrect accounting

On top of a pull the plug architecture, OAuth-based services as popularly implemented will apply limits to how and when a particular application can make use of the service in question. For example, EVS might enforce that any specific application which uses EVS can only upload 100 videos in a 24-hour period. They may even charge the application vendor automatically for usage above that amount. As a result, if a camcorder bundles software to upload videos to EVS, their entire client-base can only upload 100 videos in a 24-hour period, even though each client has their own account with EVS. If one camcorder owner is particularly active one day and uploads a lot of videos to EVS, all other camcorder owners are now either locked out till the next day or will cause the camcorder vendor to be subject to additional fees. Worse, in the latter case, since the application performing the uploads is stand-alone without any intrinsic communication with any of the other upload applications, there is no way for the camcorder vendor to ensure that their limit is adhered to without significant overhead and a centralized tracking framework. Finally, many OAuth-based systems which do not change for overuse will simply pull the plug on third-party services which they see repeatedly going over their limits, holding the third-party service responsible for their users’ actions instead of terminating or charging the overactive users directly. This entire architecture is a scalability nightmare for third-party service providers, as every camcorder the vendor sells now brings them closer to the point where EVS might shut them down and destroy their business.

Most non-OAuth-based services usually have normal accounting in place where limits of the service are applied to each individual user or organization of users (depending on whether the service is for personal-use or enterprise-level, respectively). OAuth as popularly implemented, however, groups together completely unrelated users and organizations, and makes all of them subject to the whims of one.

A “simple” workaround for incorrect accounting is to require each user or organization who wants to use some application with EVS to go apply for their own developer account. This, though, has the unfortunate consequence of forcing every camcorder buyer to figure out for themselves how to obtain a developer account, a process which is often far from simple. Then the user will have to figure out how to set up the camcorder software to use that account, increasing the possibility of human error.

I took the above described approach with an application I wrote about a year ago which integrates with a Google service, and every first-time user of it has to log into the Google Developer Console and perform 15-20 steps before they can use the application. Besides being annoying, I found I couldn't even give clear guidelines on how to perform these steps, as Google has completely restructured their developer console and renamed things half a dozen times in the past year. Even the first time I wrote a manual for navigating the console and selecting the right options, the manual became obsolete the very day after I published it. I can't point to any documentation on Google's side either, because they have no A to Z documentation specifically for obtaining the specific kind of OAuth credentials necessary for the application to work with the service in question.

The sane approach as used by non-OAuth-based services would be to allow every user or organization account manager (again, depending on whether the service is enterprise-level or not) to have a quick and easy to use control panel which can generate API access tokens for any service which is part of the account, with whatever permissions are needed. However OAuth as popularly implemented never seems to do this. Some OAuth-based services I've seen even require manual approval every time a user applies for a developer account. All this means using OAuth as popularly implemented creates considerable extra burden on the support staff for EVS, the camcorder vendor, and all of their users.

URI lock-in / Application incompatibility

OAuth as popularly implemented requires that a URI be provided up front to EVS when registering for a developer account or application credentials to be used as part of the authentication process in the new application. Remember, this URI will be used every time a user in the third-party service authenticates with the OAuth-based service. After the user logs in, the EVS special login pages will direct the user's browser to the specified URI with the tokens required to access the APIs. Some OAuth-based services will only allow for a single URI up front, while some other will allow several URIs to be entered. In the latter case, when the third-party service initially directs the user's browser to EVS's special OAuth login page, it can also specify which of previously enumerated return URIs to use.

If only one URI is allowed, or the amount of allowed URIs is not enough, often developers will find themselves being forced into opening themselves up to attacks discussed above under Cross-site request forgeries. But this is only the beginning of the issues this requirement causes.

OAuth as popularly implemented also tends to think that every use of it is by a web application built using the software as a service (SaaS) model. If some product, say AFCP, is installed on-premise and deployed on each individual client's personal domain, what URIs do the vendors of AFCP provide when registering AFCP for EVS? This is even more ridiculous when the application using EVS is a desktop application like the camcorder software. Such software has no associated website at all! How are these applications supposed to work with these OAuth-based APIs?

It should be noted that getting a plain HTTP client, such as cURL, is readily available in every major programming language, and can be used in any kind of application. Web browsers with modern features cannot be used in non-graphical clients, such as command-line/terminal applications, and are only available in some programming languages. This means that OAuth-based APIs are severely limited in what kinds of applications they can be used with, making many desired use-cases impossible. It should be noted that many of the popular OAuth based services also require JavaScript on either their special OAuth login pages, or as part of the subsequent redirect process, further complicating simple usage in an application.

Even for SaaS products, if it's deployed on regionally diverse domains (,, etc…) and EVS does not allow for entering enough URIs, then what? What about situations where every client gets their own sub-directory or sub-domain when using the service, how does one pre-register these or deal with the case when the amount of URIs required exceeds the amount EVS allows?

Even if EVS is a service which allows post-editing of the URI white-list, and allows for a nearly unlimited amount of URIs to be entered, how does the list get updated exactly? I have not seen a single OAuth-based service which provides any meta-APIs for modifying the URI white-list. In today's day and age, most SaaS deployments are or should be automated. When a client registers for a service, credit cards can be automatically processed, servers automatically deployed, sub-domains automatically added to DNS, initial credentials automatically e-mailed to the administrator, and so on. But how do the new URIs get added for any OAuth-based services used by the just deployed SaaS instance? Manually entry is utterly unacceptable and completely unscalable.

The workaround most suggest is to have some website set up which handles redirection for all clients and users. However, besides the aforementioned security issues when not done carefully, this can get expensive fast. In order to have all requests processed by a fixed location, enough load balanced infrastructure needs to be set up to handle the load, even though it could otherwise have been handled by the same server or servers which handle the rest of the service for the given client. This also binds on-premise and desktop applications to this extra website, and will be unavailable if the extra website goes down for some reason. This has now become an annoying and costly dependency solely to manage a misfeature.

Another workaround suggested for desktop applications that don't want to be bound to a website is to build in an HTTP server into the application, and set the return URI to http://localhost/. It's bad enough that a web browser - often a full featured one with JavaScript support - needs to be built into the desktop application just to handle the login process, now they recommend a web server should be built-in too! I should point out, though, that whitelisting http://localhost/ is not enough, as that URL implies the server is running on port 80. Not every application can grab that port, nor is the port always available, as something else may be using it. To make a robust application that can handle every eventuality as best as possible, one also needs to whitelist http://localhost:1/, http://localhost:2/, ..., http://localhost:65534/, http://localhost:65535/. This probably sounds ridiculous to you, and that's because it is. This also doesn't even account for the fact that some security software may get cranky or scare users if it finds an application is launching a server.

Being faced with this and some of the previous issues and finding only poor solutions offered, I came up with a completely different solution which I use with some OAuth-based services. I created a small web application that I can throw up on any server which asks in a web-based form to be populated with a client_id, client_secret, and anything else the OAuth-based service requires from what it thinks is an application. After submitting the details, the application redirects the user to the special OAuth login page, and after redirected back, the application displays whatever tokens it just got. The user can then manually paste these tokens into the real application they want to use which does not need to be tied down to any site nor requires browsers, servers, and graphical interfaces be used by the real application.

My above solution first requires users register for their own application or developer account, whitelist whatever the URI is to the small web application, paste their data into the small web application, log in, get the tokens, and paste those into the real application. It works well, circumvents any needs for a web browser and redirect_uri, and it's only a mere 20-25 steps for every user to perform. This would be much simpler for the users if the OAuth-based service itself showed them the courtesy of just supplying a page in their account where they can generate tokens with whatever permissions they wanted. Instead, these services would rather force third party developers to provide such finery, and make their users lose their minds.

Open-source unfriendly

A minor point to the above, OAuth is also unfriendly to open source applications, because every user making use of it is required to register their own developer account in addition to whatever user account they already have with a service. It would be unsafe to include credentials in the source or within binary packages which can be stolen, see Masquerading as an OAuth-using service above. This is on top of all the previous remarks about not knowing what URI to use, incorrect accounting, and all the other limitations.

Low availability

Another major flaw with OAuth as popularly implemented is its low availability (which is the opposite of high availability). OAuth-based systems differ as to the exact details, but they usually expire the tokens they provide that are required to be used with the actual API calls. Some of them allow a way to refresh them, but usually only for a limited amount of time. These systems require that the user of an account be present to re-authenticate with the service like clockwork. Besides being annoying, requiring re-authentication in middle of an operation and being able to continue the process after doing so may cause the design of the platform to fail in ways described above under the issue Cross-site request forgeries.

Now in the case of the camcorder software, where the user was using the provided software to upload to EVS for a while, what happens when the tokens expire? Say the user queued up a bunch of videos and then went camping for the weekend. They come home to find the first few videos uploaded, and then the rest failed because they were not around to re-authenticate. This user will be extremely annoyed, especially if they promised someone the videos would be up by a certain time before they left.

When we consider our usage scenario with AFCP, this requirement to re-authenticate gets even worse. Normally when an administrator assigns someone new to a department, AFCP runs through the list of all integrated users in that department, and adds permission for this new user to access the EVS videos of the other users in the same department. However, if one of those previously existing users needs to re-authenticate, AFCP cannot automatically assign permissions for accessing videos to the newly added user. If the videos of the particular user who needs to re-authenticate is crucial for training a new employee, and the user is on some extended leave (vacation, maternity, etc...), the new employee cannot even be trained.

This expiratory handicap can make sense in various usage scenarios, but completely destroys what EVS integration with AFCP is trying to accomplish. If your usage scenario is AFCP, you really need to look for a service to use which does not use expiring tokens, which OAuth as popularly implemented unfortunately does. However, I did come up with a workaround which I use with some of my applications.

If a platform needs to re-authenticate on behalf of a user when they're not around, one would need their credentials to do so. I've exploited the flaw described above - Stealing credentials / gaining elevated Access, in which I prompt users for their credentials when they log in, store them (encrypted of course), and reuse their credentials automatically when tokens expire. This technique works as long as the user does not change their password and additional authentication factors are not in play.

I created a SaaS application which exploits this flaw over two years ago. Several thousands of users have since willingly entered their credentials into the application, and not a single one of them has ever complained or noticed anything suspicious. Better yet, the vendor behind the OAuth-based service I built upon heard about my application from some of their users, and was pleased as to how they gained access to a larger user base. They contacted my employer and asked if we could provide them with some accounts on our platform for their sales department to show off to prospective clients, as well as a few other key personnel. We did so, and have since captured the credentials of several of their high ranking employees, including an executive responsible for managing their OAuth-based service. Not one of them noticed anything wrong with what we were doing, which goes to show that this is a viable workaround - however unorthodox.

While the above technique can turn a useless OAuth service into something profitable, it'd be better if it was achievable without needing to undermine security, defeat the few benefits of OAuth, and rely on exploitable flaws. I'll discuss below what really should be done instead of trying to always limit usage to the point that a service becomes unusable.

Not enterprise-ready

All the above usability issue sections show that OAuth as popularly implemented is not ready for the enterprise market. Contracts with OAuth based service providers do not actually cover the services you want, accounting is incorrect for organizations making them subject to unrelated third parties, there's extra setup annoyance, it’s not scalable, and the services repeatedly fail to work without manual user intervention from specific users. All this on top of not necessarily being able to conform with an organization’s security requirements.

However a real problem with OAuth-based services is that their APIs always seem to be geared towards only managing things for a single user as themselves. When someone personally gets an account for a service, they obviously do not want others to be able to take control of their account. But when an organization at the enterprise level purchases many accounts for their employees company-wide, they expect to have full control over all accounts, there is no room for individuals. In enterprise scenarios, no AFCP user should even be able to opt-out of the EVS usage, as the higher-ups want all resources within a department to be accessible to the entire department. Therefore, in order to be feasible for an enterprise, whoever or whatever is in charge of administrating all these accounts needs to be able to perform any action on behalf of any user. If this requirement is not met, the enterprise company will need to find a different service which does make this possible.

I know of several OAuth-based services which in their front-ends for non-API usage allows for companies to set up authentication to their services using SAML. With SAML, any login request signed by a particular private key is able to gain entry to a platform as the user who is identified in the signed request. Whoever is in charge of managing the SAML identity provider and its private keys, usually the IT staff at the companies, can masquerade as any user they please and perform needed activities on their behalf.

What companies really want when they purchase a package with a service is to use an automated system to perform needed activities as required on behalf of their personnel. The APIs of the OAuth-based services, however, don't provide a way for any user - even at the administrator level - to perform activities on behalf of other users, nor do they provide a way to acquire tokens representing those lower-level users to use with the APIs on their behalf. An administrator cannot assign permissions for any videos in EVS except what they themselves have uploaded. When I asked developers of these services why not, they responded that providing such a feature would weaken the security of their platform. Yet these services which support SAML already have their security “weakened” in this way, though I fail to see how allowing administrators to effectively administrate their users, a situation which is usually considered desirable, can be called a “weakness”.

All in all, we see that the typical service with APIs built upon the foundation of OAuth as popularly implemented is designed and maintained with myopia regarding what enterprise customers actually want to achieve with a system. These APIs generally don't allow for anything to be done which couldn't already be done the same way with their existing user interface. However if you can't build anything that wasn't directly achievable with the provided interface, why bother offering APIs at all? Providing APIs is not so that the exact same UI with the same limited feature-set can be recreated over and over in other contexts, since today with SSO technology to access a website (such as SAML), there's no real point in that. The point in providing APIs is so that something new can be created which can offer added value to a service. If it's not possible to do more with the APIs than what is already built-in, then the APIs are of little value and no self-respecting enterprise is going to take the product seriously.

Don't get me wrong, with limited APIs in place, there are still those making third party applications. However these applications are generally just embedding a subset of a service’s existing features into a different context with no real added value. If a third-party application is actually providing something with added value with these crippled APIs, they end up also requiring users to perform dozens of steps and tons of copying and pasting to accomplish even the simplest of tasks. In such a situation, odds are a discerning buyer is not going to consider buying that product for all personnel, especially when there are alternatives available which aren't such a pain to use. A good rule of thumb, bad integrations from otherwise competent developers are the result of bad APIs. Therefore, if all of the so called “integrations” being created for a service either lack added value or are extremely clunky, it’s probably an indication that the APIs are lacking what enterprises need. If your product lacks what enterprises need, you can expect that most enterprises will not be purchasing your product.

It should be noted that the only major services which have thriving OAuth-based ecosystems are platforms designed specifically for individual user use, and are not geared for enterprise use-cases. Facebook and Twitter (both of whom were in part responsible for the formation and adoption of OAuth), have a huge repertoire of apps making use of them. Google is another interesting example. Several applications, platforms, and services exist which make use of Google’s OAuth APIs, but all of these are noticeably geared towards individual Google accounts, despite the fact that Google has a large business offering as well. In contrast, Google Apps for Business services generally offer alternative systems and protocols which are more appropriate for the enterprise market than OAuth, as they recognize their OAuth-based APIs to be incapable of providing the needed functionality.

Section conclusion

While the security of OAuth as popularly implemented is not all that it's considered to be, the worst part about it is how crippling it is to actually work with. Many of the things OAuth sets out to accomplish are actually detrimental, especially in enterprise settings, and at best, you'll need to find ridiculous workarounds to even get any use at all out of a service whose APIs are built upon OAuth.

The following is a mostly accurate depiction from one of my colleagues as to where the world with OAuth is heading:

Allow me to present an alternative to OAuth which provides the same level of functionality and security but is far simpler to implement. We call it NoAuth. The protocol is as follows: No one may ever authenticate, period. Simple, effective, and we estimate that it will take developers a mere fraction of the implementation time of OAuth, cutting your costs significantly. “NoAuth, because the future deserves absolute impenetrability.”

A key misdesign of OAuth as popularly implemented is thinking that all external services should be mistrusted equally. Let administrators define what should and shouldn't be done with a service, and what capabilities should be made available with various API tokens. Don't make this decision for them and limit what can be done with a service in its entirety just because there can be some rogue applications out there.

For applications I provide which make use of API services, I frequently get clients who ask me what exactly is my system doing that it needs certain permissions, and that's okay. Administrators are capable of deciding what they want or don't want to allow and what the ramifications may be.

My employer is commonly approached by third parties asking us to integrate some service with another service, telling us how much revenue we'll pull from sales if we partner with them. Every time we find out one of these services is using OAuth we groan, because almost always, it means the project is infeasible. Yet the third party thinks there must be some magical way to do it because we've done some amazing things with other third parties which are not using OAuth. When we ask them to improve their APIs or drop this ridiculousness with OAuth, they claim they can't because this is how it has to be done.

More often than not, we find whatever is desired really is not feasible, and the workarounds are either not possible or too ridiculous, time-consuming, and annoying to the end-user for the case at hand. These third parties beg us to then just do something with it, as if that were a sane business practice. We're not going to create some product for which there's no business case and doesn't look like it'll break even, let alone make a profit.

I've seen a number of these projects come and go over the years. Usually the third party can't find anyone dumb enough to waste their time and effort on working with them, although on occasion they do. The outcome is always something which doesn't sell well, and the third party throws in the towel a couple of months later.

Even large enterprise organizations are coming up with some new product every year that they then try to force on the market, but time after time, these never seem to go anywhere. Despite the fact that the product has no real use, and other businesses can find no way to make it useful, they blame everything but a crucial issue at the heart of the matter. Instead of fixing the actual flaws preventing integration, the lifeblood of enterprise adoption and retention, they think it must something else, discontinue the product, and try releasing a different but similarly crippled product the next year.

Alternatives to OAuth as popularly implemented

What do proper OAuth-based designs look like?

Now that we've seen that OAuth as popularly implemented is utterly broken, when does OAuth actually work?

OAuth systems that adhere mostly to the earlier OAuth specifications and concepts are generally more secure and less broken than those based on later specifications. This is not to say that all OAuth 1.0 implementations are secure, but they're usually less problematic. These systems will normally follow one of two distinct approaches:
  • By providing users the ability to directly generate access tokens in their account which they can dole out to software they wish to integrate, a lot of the silly requirements and insecure transfers and redirects are bypassed.
  • By using a system where the client_secret does not function as a piece of data which is passed verbatim like a common password, but is instead itself a cryptographic shared secret used to generate authentication codes, the remainder of the token system, silly requirements, and insecure transfers and redirects are bypassed. In these systems, users generally do not even have their own credentials and only use SSO mechanisms.
Precious few OAuth-based systems are designed like this though, and these systems generally look nothing like OAuth as used everywhere else. Since these systems stick closer to the OAuth 1.0 specifications, which is officially deprecated, systems using this approach eventually get "updated" to be restructured with all sorts of OAuth 2.0 concepts and additions, thereby ruining their security and usability. This is a reason I'm hesitant to condone anything OAuth based, because even if using an earlier, more operable style of OAuth, some manager is going to have the bright idea that the system will need "improving" and will break it. Better to use something else altogether than begging for problems.

Other options

Looking for other options, people often want to know what other frameworks are out there. However, one does not need some framework to achieve a well understood and secure design. As is, every service has their own take on what OAuth looks like, so there really is no exact approach on how authorization works anyway. Hunting for a framework is often over-complexifying what can be done simply. The only really difficult component that requires a good specification is how to sign variables to prevent tampering with key parameters used, and most OAuth-based implementations do nothing of the sort anyway.

The largest provider of web services on the market today is Amazon. They are the premier provider for enterprises the world over, and utterly dwarf everyone else with a whopping greater than 30% combined market share. Amazon's approach is to provide all their accounts and account administrators with access to a control panel where they can generate application credentials. These credentials can be specified as to what Amazon services they can work with, what actions they can perform in those services, and what permissions they have to work on. These credentials can be revoked by the account holder at any time if necessary.

Amazon's authentication and authorization techniques for their APIs do not require any redirection methods which are inherently limiting and potentially unsafe. Amazon's protocol never sends along any credentials directly, rather they're used for signing data, and can ensure parameters remain tamper-proof if there's any need to send them through a browser.

Amazon's design has proper usage accounting, includes API usage as part of every account, and all API authentication and authorization is initiated from the Amazon side with the creation of application credentials from their control panel. These credentials are then used directly in the API process without any sort of additional token exchange system. This design achieves all the real security objectives OAuth as popularly implemented achieves, and it also avoids all the security and usability issues enumerated above.

One downside I have to say about Amazon is that their permission system is somewhat confusing and not all that user friendly. This happens to be true though of most control panels, and in any case, is a matter of user interface design and is not a mark against the authorization process itself. Also, Amazon's control panel can be navigated fairly quickly and even be used with their APIs, unlike, say, Google's, which, as far as I know, has no meta-APIs, and requires at least a dozen steps to do anything with it.

Amazon's authentication and authorization method is also copied by several other service providers on the market. Google themselves even allow for it in certain of their enterprise products. Google themselves also acknowledge that a pure OAuth design is poorly suited towards enterprise services, and for their enterprise services, they recommend the use of JSON Web Tokens.

JWT is a specification for allowing SSO or API usage between services.  In many ways JWT is like SAML, although unlike SAML which is confusing, built upon XML Security (which is anything but secure), and not geared for API use, JWT achieves the primary SAML objectives in a simple and easy to use manner without all the headaches. If you have an HMAC implementation and know how to structure and parse JSON, then you can use JWT. For those of you who want something off the shelf, there are plenty of JWT libraries already available.

Google’s use of JWT is more advanced than typical though, and instead of HMAC, they require the use of RSA digital signatures which is a more advanced, and less popular concept than HMAC in this area. Google's control panel allows account administrators to generate a new key-pair for their enterprise services, and download the private key to use for signing API log-ins. While this is more secure than HMAC, Google really over-complexifies the whole process, not to mention that they completely redesign their control panel frequently, making it confusing to repeatedly use. I recommend looking instead at what others are doing with JWT if you need examples.

Another technique being used is that of services allowing definition of what kind of permissions third parties need in some kind of XML or JSON file that they can post on a web site. Users can then visit a page in their account where they can paste the URL to this file (or paste the contents of it), and the service will display a list of what kind of permissions the external service or application wants to use and any descriptive information it may contain. If users want to approve this, they can generate credentials which they can then paste into the third party application or service they are using. Users can later revoke the credentials if they want to disable the third party product. This is also a very secure design which doesn't have any ridiculous burdens placed on developers, includes API services for all accounts, provides permissions, and initiates the flow with the service itself, not the third party.

All you really need from the service-side in order to manage authorization is some panel which allows users with the appropriate role (administrator or account owner) to generate API usage credentials which each have permissions and a possible expiration (if desired) assigned to them. These credentials can then be used over any secure authentication system you choose, such as something simple like HTTP Basic Authentication over HTTPS, which is available with practically every HTTP library available, HTTP Digest Authentication, which is more secure and supported by most high-grade libraries, or something else based on authentication codes utilizing a cryptographic technology which does not require any credentials ever being passed over the network, such as HMAC, RSA, or Elliptic Curves. HMAC in particular is already in use by nearly everyone implementing some form of authorization or authentication (including Amazon and even some OAuth implementations).

These various well established techniques decrease the burden of needing to study the effects of one framework’s interaction on others, such as those for anti-CSRF, in order to create a secure platform, and can generally be implemented in a modular manner which can simply be dropped into an existing architecture. They avoid the possibility for stealing the user's or the application's credentials. They also don't require any constant use of elaborate CSPRNGs. These kinds of systems existed long before OAuth and are popular today too. OAuth may have better security than some poorly designed systems which require users’ personal credentials and have other weaknesses, but OAuth is not a substitute for the real designs that already existed. The problems that OAuth claims to solve do not actually exist in the existing well-designed systems, and OAuth as popularly implemented actually introduces many of the problems it claims to solve, along with several others which never existed in the first place. Despite the hype, OAuth does not inherently provide amazing security, and due to the numerous drawbacks and implementation difficulties, the other well-thought-out options are vastly better.

If you're going to be designing a service and provide API access, please, really think about what you're trying to achieve, and don't just copy what you see others do or buy into ridiculous hype. If you must copy someone, try to copy Amazon (the best), Rackspace, IBM SoftLayer, Linode, VULTR, Zoho, Zoom, or others who seem to currently have some inkling on how to structure a straight-forward and sound authentication system for APIs.


«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 400 of 566   Newer›   Newest»
Game Richer said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Game Richer said...

Krunker Unblocked

shell shockers unblocked

Unblocked games 66

free games unblocked
tambayan pinoy

Game Richer said...

unblocked hacked games

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
angularjs online training
top angularjs online training
best angularjs online training

Bhagya Lakshsmi said...

Watch Korean In English Subtitle Dramas and Movies Online Free. Watch Korean Dramas and Movies in Full HD. Korean Dramas and Movies EngSub has been released to watch it first on
Click Here For More Info...

Bhagya Lakshsmi said...

I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. Know more intersting things to click here..

JunicaQueen said...

Selamat Datang Di Situs AGEN BANDARQ

Rasakan sensasi serunya bermain di Situs AGEN BANDARQ
Yang Merupakan Agen Bandarq, Domino 99, Dan Bandar Poker Online Terpercaya di asia hadir untuk anda semua dengan permainan permainan menarik dan bonus menarik untuk anda semua.

Rasakan Sensasi serunya bermain di CrownQQ, Agen BandarQ Yang 100% Gampang Menang
Games Yang di Hadirkan CrownQQ :

=> Poker
=> Bandar Poker
=> Domino99
=> BandarQ
=> AduQ
=> Sakong
=> Capsa Susum
=> Bandar66 (ADU BALAK)
=> Perang Baccarat (New Game)

Promo Yang Berlaku Saat ini:

=> Bonus Refferal 20% ( OTOMATIS )
=> Bonus Turn Over 0,5% (SETIAP SENIN )
=> Minimal Depo Rp. 20.000,-
=> Minimal WD Rp. 20.000,-

Pelayanan dan Sistem Di Situs CROWNQQ :

=> 100% Member Asli Pemain vs Pemain ( NO ROBOT & ADMIN )
=> Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
=> Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
=> Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android & IOS
=> Dilayani Dengan 5 Bank Terbaik

<< Contact_Us >>
WHATSAPP : +855882357563
TELEGRAM : +855882357563



CROWNQQ | Agen BandarQ | BandarQ Online | AduQ Online | DominoQQ Terbaik

Malcom Marshall said...

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.

digital marketing course in chennai
digital marketing training in chennai
seo training in chennai
online digital marketing training
best marketing books
best marketing books for beginners
best marketing books for entrepreneurs
best marketing books in india
digital marketing course fees
high pr social bookmarking sites
high pr directory submission sites
best seo service in chennai

Anonymous said...

Nanne Parmar

Best Guide on Places To Visit in Yercaud - You Need To Know
Travel Guide on Place To Visit Gwalior - You Need To Know
Free Guide on Top 15 Nainital Places to Visit and Do Things - You Need To Know
An Simple Guide For 5 Steps To Create Website Free - You Need To Know

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
workday studio online training
best workday studio online training
top workday studio online training

Bandar Bola Online said...

Bhanu Sree said...

Very informative and creative content. This concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge.thanks for sharing
UI Path Online Training
UI Path Training in Hyderabad

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
microservices online training

Bandar Bola Online said...

meritstep Technology said...

Thanks for Sharing This Article.It is very so much valuable content. I hope these Commenting lists will help to my website
workday studio online training
best workday studio online training
top workday studio online training

tech support said... 2652 6968 6978 5055

Rajesh Anbu said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.
aws Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
hadoop Training in Bangalore
angular js Training in Bangalore
bigdata analytics Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
aws Training in Bangalore

Mary Magdalene said... 2652 6968 6978 5055

Yourdoorstep said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

court marriage in delhi ncr
court marriage in delhi
court marriage in noida
court marriage in ghaziabad
court marriage in gurgaon
court marriage in faridabad
court marriage in greater noida
name change online
court marriage in chandigarh
court marriage in bangalore

akash said...

spotify premium APK

how to text bomb someone anonymously

how to get ios apps on android

best android apk download site

how to download photos from icloud to PC

icloud removal tool

how to view archived messages on facebook messenger android

send 1000 text messages at once app


Situs Judi Online Terpercaya said...


Yang Merupakan Agen Bandarq, Domino 99, Dan Bandar Poker Online Terpercaya di asia hadir untuk anda semua dengan permainan permainan menarik dan bonus menarik untuk anda semua

Bonus yang diberikan NagaQQ :
* Bonus rollingan 0.5%,setiap senin di bagikannya
* Bonus Refferal 10% + 10%,seumur hidup
* Bonus Jackpot, yang dapat anda dapatkan dengan mudah
* Minimal Depo 15.000
* Minimal WD 20.000

Memegang Gelar atau title sebagai AGEN BANDARQ Terbaik di masanya

Games Yang di Hadirkan NagaQQ :
* Poker Online
* BandarQ
* Domino99
* Bandar Poker
* Bandar66
* Sakong
* Capsa Susun
* AduQ
* Perang Bacarrat (New Game)

Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
Website : NAGAQQ
Facebook : NagaQQ Official
WHATSAPP : +855977509035
Line : Cs_nagaQQ
TELEGRAM : +855967014811

agen bandarq terbaik
Winner NagaQQ
Daftar NagaQQ

Eric Kye said...

Are you stuck with how to setup Android TV and Remote? Just visit our page and then follow the instructions for the setup.

John Peter said...

This is a very great post and the way you express your all post details that is too good. thanks for sharing healthytips

greyhankin said...

If you would like to know the features and specifications of the Roku remote app, the steps to activate Roku using then it's good to read the latest articles and blog posts in our page @ Activation code

Aiden Jangra said...

Great information you have shared through this article. we have a professional team to offer the required guidance for HP Printer Setup to download the compatible Drivers and Fix HP Printer error code 0x610000f6.

Roku-comlink said...

Roku ultra streaming device is one of the top brands in the market when we compare to the other streaming device models. You can use for obtaining your Roku Com Link and troubleshooting errors during the activation process.

Tomroy said...

McAfee is the fastest, as it claims, that their reaction time in terms of solving customer troubles is the minimum.
||McAfee Coustomer Support Phone Number
||mcafee customer support number
||mcafee support
||mcafee tech support
||mcafee tech support phone number
||mcafee customer service number
||mcafee tech support usa
||mcafee tech support canada
||mcafee help
||mcafee support phone number
||mcafee telephone support number
||mcafee help desk for antivirus
||go to mcafee support
||mcafee 24x7 technical support number
||mcafee live chat technical support
||mcafee phone number tech support
||mcafee technical support usa
||mcafee help support canada

Inoventic Creative Agency said...

Hello Admin!

Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuffs like this. If you are looking for the Advertising Agency in Chennai | Printing in Chennai , Visit Inoventic Creative Agency Today..

Inoventic Creative Agency said...

Hello Admin!

Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuffs like this. If you are looking for the Advertising Agency in Chennai | Printing in Chennai , Visit Inoventic Creative Agency Today..

Inoventic Creative Agency said...

Hello Admin!

Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuffs like this. If you are looking for the Advertising Agency in Chennai | Printing in Chennai , Visit Inoventic Creative Agency Today..

Inoventic Creative Agency said...

Hello Admin!

Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuffs like this. If you are looking for the Advertising Agency in Chennai | Printing in Chennai , Visit Inoventic Creative Agency Today..

Inoventic Creative Agency said...

Hello Admin!

Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuffs like this. If you are looking for the Advertising Agency in Chennai | Printing in Chennai , Visit Inoventic Creative Agency Today..

domt said...

hp envy photo 7855 driver

honlith said...

hp envy photo 7855 driver

Nandhini said...

Data Science with Python Training in BTM
UI and UX Training in BTM
Angular training in BTM
Web designing Training in BTM
Digital Marketing Training in BTM

Jeffery king said...

hp envy photo 7855 driver

hrroman said...

If you are stuck with your online management assignment then in this case you can opt for our Marketing Assignment help. we provide the best assignment assignment help online .
We also provide Market segmentation Assignment help. for students across the globe.
for more information contact us +16692714848

Ramesh ji said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

name change procedure in india
name change procedure in punjab
name change procedure in rajasthan
name change procedure in maharashtra
name change procedure in andhra pradesh
name change procedure in lucknow
name change procedure in bihar
name change procedure in chandigarh
name change procedure in karnataka
name change procedure in delhi

i Digital Academy said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice information with us...
Digital Marketing in Bangalore

Kuma Herbals said...

Thanks for sharing this information with us...
Unani Treatment in Bangalore

Siva Kumar said...

ahmet altan said...

Cratossporting canlı bahis sitesi

ahmet altan said...

Cratosslot canlı casino 

RIA Institute of Technology said...

Thanks for sharing valuable information...
Oracle Training in Bangalore

sammer mark said...

Thank you for the Post I like to read your post. I am waiting for your new blog. Keep it up. If my <a href="”>123.hp/setup</a> then what I will do? This is most important question in the 123 hp printer setup issues now day. If you have this type issues call our Toll-Free number at any time anywhere 24 x 7.

Home Appliance Services said...

This is a nice blog. Good clean and nice informative blog. I will be coming back soon, Thanks for posting some great information.
We not only deal in setup but also provides you with all types of AC repair service. LG AC Service Centre in Kolkata only charges the nominal price for the service of LG AC.

Door Step India said...

Thanks for this sharing this informative blog. I'm truly impress with your helpful information.Are you searching door step repair service centre? Door Step India gives you options to choose according your appliance needs with India's No.1 service repair centre.

Door Step India said...

Thanks for this sharing this informative blog. I'm truly impress with your helpful information.Are you searching door step repair service centre? Door Step India gives you options to choose according your appliance needs with India's No.1 service repair centre.

Zoe said...

Holiday Camps - We provide the best online learning coaching for Stem Education Coding in Singapore. Get the best online Stem Education Coding for your kids.
accent pillow case baby burlap living room deco
accent pillow case baby canvas nursery
personalised teacher gifts

Zoe said...

Thanks for sharing amazing information.Gain the knowledge and hands-on experience.
floral cushion covers
pillow cases floral
vintage cushion covers

Mr Rahman said...

Really Nice Post & keep up the good work.
Oflox Is The Best Digital Marketing Company In Dehradun Or Website Design Company In Dehradun

Mr Rahman said...

Really Very helpful Post & thanks for sharing & keep up the good work.
Oflox Is The Best Digital Marketing Company In Dehradun Or Website Design Company In Dehradun

The Qb Payroll said...

QuickBooks is an advanced accounting application, still in many instances occurs with technical faults. For resolution of such issues, dial QuickBooks Customer Service Number 1-833-780-0086. Here, you will connect with Highly skilled professionals who provide Customer oriented results. For More Visit:

The Qb Payroll said...

The issues in QuickBooks can’t be resisted but it can be avoided or resolved with the valuable assistance given by QB experts. The experts are deployed on the support for which users have to dial QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number 1-833-780-0086. Read More:

The Qb Payroll said...

Call us at QuickBooks Support Number 1-833-780-0086 if you got stuck somewhere in between. Whether it’s due to error issues or technical snags or with some questions. Resolve it immediately with the eminent assistance given by our QB Professionals.

pricilia angela said...


Website paling ternama dan paling terpercaya di Asia ^^
Sistem pelayanan 24 Jam Non-Stop bersama dengan CS Berpengalaman respon tercepat :)
Memiliki 8 Jenis game yang sangat digemari oleh seluruh peminat poker / domino99

- Adu Q
- Bandar Q
- Poker Luck
- Pai Qiu
- Texas Hold'em
- Omaha Poker
- Domino99
- Slot Game

Permainan Judi online yang menggunakan uang asli dan mendapatkan uang asli ^^
* Minimal Deposit : 10.000
* Minimal Withdraw : 20.000
* Deposit dan Withdraw 24 jam Non stop ( Kecuali Bank offline / gangguan )
* Bonus REFFERAL 20 % Seumur hidup tanpa syarat
* Bonus Cashback 0.5 % Dibagikan Setiap Hari Senin
* Proses Deposit & Withdraw PALING CEPAT
* Sistem keamanan Terbaru & Terjamin
* Poker Online Terpercaya
* Live chat yang Responsive
* Support lebih banyak bank LOKAL

#agenonline, #agenjudionline, #judionline, #agentaruhanjudionline, #situstaruhanjudi,#situspoker, #judipoker, #pokeronline, #pokerdomino, #agentaruhanpoker, #agentaruhanonline, #agenjuditerpercaya, #agenjudipoker, #agenpoker, #bursataruhan, #taruhanpoker, #taruhanonline, #taruhanjudipoker, #Agen Judi BandarQ, #Bandar Judi AduQQ, #Bandar Taruhan Poker, #Situs Taruhan Poker, #Daftar Poker Online, #Bandar Judi BandarQ, #Bandar #Situs Taruhan Poker, #Agen Poker Terbaik, #Bandar Poker Domino,# Judi Online Indonesia, #Agen Slot, #Slot Machine, #Situs Slot Online, #Agen Domino99, #Agen Judi Online

The Qb Payroll said...

QuickBooks Customer Service Number
QuickBooks Customer Service
QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Desktop Support Phone Number

Venkatesh CS said...

Excellent Blog. Thank you so much for sharing.
salesforce training in chennai
salesforce training in omr
salesforce training in velachery
salesforce training and placement in chennai
salesforce course fee in chennai
salesforce course in chennai
salesforce certification in chennai
salesforce training institutes in chennai
salesforce training center in chennai
salesforce course in omr
salesforce course in velachery
best salesforce training institute in chennai
best salesforce training in chennai

Aruna said...

It's really a nice and useful piece of information about Java. I'm satisfied that you shared this helpful information with us.Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Java training in chennai | Java training in annanagar | Java training in omr | Java training in porur | Java training in tambaram | Java training in velachery

The Qb Payroll said...

Suffering with the technical snag of QuickBooks? Don’t worry, ring us on QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number 1-833-780-0086. Our highly experienced & learned experts are available round the clock to offer assistance.

Rajesh said...

It is actually a great and helpful piece of information about Java. I am satisfied that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.
Java training in chennai | Java training in annanagar | Java training in omr | Java training in porur | Java training in tambaram | Java training in velachery

Salman said...

Effective blog with a lot of information. I just Shared you the link below for Courses .They really provide good level of training and Placement,I just Had Java Classes in this institute,Just Check This Link You can get it more information about the Java course.

Java training in chennai | Java training in annanagar | Java training in omr | Java training in porur | Java training in tambaram | Java training in velachery

The Qb Payroll said...

QuickBooks Desktop Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number Oregon
QuickBooks Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number Texas
QuickBooks Support Phone Number Atlanta
QuickBooks Toll Free Phone Number
QuickBooks Support Phone Number New York
QuickBooks Support Phone Number Hawaii

ravi said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

religion change
arya samaj mandir in ghaziabad
arya samaj mandir in greater bangalore
name change ads in newspaper
arya samaj mandir in punjab
arya samaj mandir in rajasthan
arya samaj mandir in noida
arya samaj mandir in gurgaon
arya samaj mandir in faridabad
arya samaj mandir in delhi

The Qb Payroll said...

If confronting any sort of technical glitch in the software. Resolve it by calling on QuickBooks Customer Service Phone Number 1-833-780-0086. Our learned & Experienced QuickBooks professionals are always presented to offer technical help. For More Visit:

The Qb Payroll said...

QuickBooks For Mac Support Phone Number
QuickBooks POS Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Customer Service Number
QuickBooks Helpline Number
QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number

Buồn thế said...

Những chia sẻ quá hay

cửa lưới dạng xếp

cửa lưới chống muỗi

lưới chống chuột

cửa lưới chống muỗi hà nội

thomas said...

Nice Blog!
Getting QuickBooks Payroll Update Error?.Get efficient solution with Our expert.
Click Here to Know How to fix QuickBooks Payroll Update Error
Dial our tech support Number for any support +1-844-908-0801.

Amily said...

Nice & Informative Blog !
When Found QuickBooks Banking Error 103, don’t get worried about it. Immediately ring a call to us at 1-855-6OO-4O6O.

Sara said...

Pinoy Tv Replay is another type of Pinoy Tambayan shows because there are different terms
for each of them so Pinoy Tambayan is also a famous Keyword and Pinoy Tv Channel are also watched and loved by the people of Phillippines.
OFWs generally can not find the place outside of their country to watch all these Pinoy Tv Shows so we are giving them a chance to bookmark our website so they can watch all of them at this place.

Nooble said...

Check out our video for Oauth JWT with us at our YouTube channel Nooble. This video will show you a simple implementation of OAuth and JPA.

SSK Law Firm said...

Being the best streaming service in the US, Roku has a keen track of all your activities using the Roku account that you create. Roku also needs you to complete the for activating the account. Here are certain things that we assist you on to complete the Roku activation.

SSK Law Firm
Criminal Lawyers in Chennai
Bail Lawyers in Chennai
Lawyers in Chennai
Lawyers in Chennai
Economic Offences Financial Fraud Lawyers in Chennai

Mayank Gupta said...

Download Latest Movies

Jenny said...

I want to thank you for this great writings. I enjoyed every detail of this. This is truly cool. If you have time, visit our website too 에볼루션 카지노 사이트

ravi kumar said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

birth certificate in delhi
name add in birth certificate
birth certificate in gurgaon
birth certificate correction
birth certificate in noida
birth certificate
birth certificate in ghaziabad
birth certificate in india
birth certificate apply online
birth certificate in bengaluru

CCC Service said...

Hi this is the nice blog, thanks for sharing us
'CCC Service
AC Service in Chennai
Fridge Service in Chennai
Washing Machine Service in Chennai
LED LCD TV Service in Chennai
Microwave Oven Service in Chennai'

Anonymous said...

python training in bangalore | python online training
artificial intelligence training in bangalore | artificial intelligence online training
aws training in Bangalore
| aws online training

machine learning training in bangalore | machine learning online training
data science training in bangalore | data science online training

Ramesh ji said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

death certificate in delhi
death certificate in bangalore
death certificate in mumbai
death certificate in faridabad
death certificate in gurgaon
death certificate in noida
duplicate driving licence delhi
death certificate online
death certificate
death certificate apply online

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing amazing information.Gain the knowledge and hands-on experience.
Oneyes Technologies
Inplant Training in Chennai
Inplant Training in Chennai for CSE IT MCA
Inplant Training in Chennai ECE EEE EIE

ravi said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

name change procedure in ghaziabad
name change procedure delhi
name change procedure gurgaon
name change in faridabad
name change in noida
name change
name change in india
name change procedure in bangalore
name change procedure in rajasthan
name change procedure in maharashtra

augustwalker said...

Do you require a HP printer setup for your macintosh working framework? Is your printer driver not appropriate for macOS? At that point visit the to get the product and driver for better working of your printer.

Govt. Latest Job said...

nice information

Chetan H said...

your blog is nice thanks for sharing information

Rajesh said...

nice Online Poker programming system is still taboo because many poker players don't understand that there are still many tricks to playing online poker outside of luck alone. This paper answers what players need to know about online poker programming and ways players can easily win on poker sites. Rajesh Pahan

Rajesh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Rajesh said...

There is a really great article, thank you for sharing and I would like to say that, please keep sharing your information for us.

Odisha Shayari


Your Blog is Awesome

Couples desire
Best Short Love story comics for Your partner, Relationship goals story


Best 15 tips for a very strong relationship. ( Couples goals, relationship goals )
Best Love feeling Quotes || 100% will become your Love partner.
LOVE QUOTES FOR HIM/HER || Create Best love story
love dedicate lines || He/she will be attracted to you.
40 Best Love Breakup Quotes
SAD QUOTES || Boring life || Alone lines


Most popular hindi BREAKUP status image, Breakup quotes HD images Part-2
Most popular hindi BREAKUP status image, Breakup quotes HD images Part-1
Best LOVE shayari HD images in hindi || poetry || Status
Tips for Building a Healthy Relationship || Love images HD
Best Husband Quotes || Missing Husband Quotes
Relationship goals mike todd || Love is blind cast
Love lines for your BF/GF || kids movies that adults will love
Relationship goals thoughts || Couples images
What are couples relationship goals? || Couples goals images


Love Quotes HD images || Best lines for relationship goals

By Admin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
By Admin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
By Admin said...

Very Good Article share...
Conspiracy theories

By Admin said...

hello friends such as motivational Article...
latest speech of Honorable mr. Ratan tata

payTm exposed by cobrapost 136 part 2 and so on....

How to learn anything easily and fast

CWE champion and upcoming champion on WWE,NXT match

Latest news said...

Very Good Information Share..
photo editing

rohit said...

Awesome bhai read this one bhai click here

CyberBOY said...

IPO in Share Market

CyberBOY said...

Carry minati Yalgar song

Pawan Mishra said...

I appreciate you and I would like to read your next post. Thanks for sharing this useful information. We know your time is very important. So, We will help you for finding many important website links that you need for every work. Just Bookmarks one website and get more website links. WhatsApp Group links: Join or share your WhatsApp Group links on our website. Join the whatsapp groups in just a single click. By Thanks for sharing your knowledge...

Abhishek Gupta said...

Great Article Fullmaza Movie 2020

Civil Service Aspirants said...

Really i found this article more informative, thanks for sharing this article! Also Check here
Civil Service Aspirants
TNPSC Tutorial in English
TNPSC Tutorial in Tamil
TNPSC Notes in English
TNPSC Materials in English
tnpsc group 1 study materials

Games said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Games said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Games said...

Very Good Information Share.. Best travel to place

Hebbare Manikantha Rao said...

nice thoughts useful in http html
lots of thanks thanks

harshni said...

nice post...
Artificial Intelligence Training in Chennai | Certification | ai training in chennai | Artificial Intelligence Course in Bangalore | Certification | ai training in bangalore | Artificial Intelligence Training in Hyderabad | Certification | ai training in hyderabad | Artificial Intelligence Online Training Course | Certification | ai Online Training | Blue Prism Training in Chennai | Certification | Blue Prism Online Training Course

MBBS in Philippines said...

UV GULLAS COLLEGE OF MEDICINE is one of Top Medical College in Philippines in Cebu city. International students have the oppertunity to study medicine in phillipines at affordable cost and world class University. The college has successful alumni who have achieved well in the fields of law, business, politics, academe, medicine, sports and other endeavors. At University of the Visayas, we prepare students for a global competition.

Direct MBBS Admissions Open: 2020-21
Mobile No: +91 90329 55688
Apply Now:

Hindi Business Idea said...

Thankue for this post. Very Great Information.

Top Free Video Editing Softwares 2020

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing Good Information
python training in bangalore | python online trainng
artificial intelligence training in bangalore | artificial intelligence online training
uipath training in bangalore | uipath online training
blockchain training in bangalore | blockchain online training

Plumbing & HVAC Services San Diego said...

ظهور نخستین سایت های شرط بندی
اما نخستین سایت های شرط بندی چگونه شکل گرفتند؟ قبل از اینکه به مبحث اصلی مقاله یعنی معرفی سایت بازی انفجار نیترو بپردازیم، بد نیست کمی با ظهور نخستین سایت های شرط بندی آشنا شویم. اگر فراموش نکرده باشید اشاره کردیم بازی های شرط بندی در گذشته محدودیت های زیادی را داشتند.
حضرات نیترو
بازی رولت

اما امروزه قدرت اینرنت باعث شده تا این بازی به سایت های شرط بندی کوچ کنند و از محدودیت مکانی خارج شوند. تاریخ دقیق ظهور سایت های شرط بندی در دسترس نمی باشد.
بتخته نرد آنلاین نیترو
تخته نرد آنلاین
بلک جک نیترو

اما با رجوع به تاریخچه بعضی از این سایت های از جمله سایت نیترو، خواهیم دریافت که پیشرفت تکنولوژی، بزرگترین ترغیب کننده برای ایجاد این سایت ها بوده است. البته مطالب گفته شده تمامی اطلاعات درباره این سایت های نمی باشد.
پوکر آنلاین نیترو
پوکر آنلاین
بلک جک

شمار سایت های شرط بندی امروزه رو به افزایش می باشد. برای مثال می توانیم به سایت نیترو اشاره کنیم. این سایت معتبر یکی از پیشگامان در این عرصه می باشد که قصد داریم در این مقاله شما را بیشتر با آن آشنا کنیم.
پاسور آنلاین نیترو
پاسور آنلاین

ترفند برد و آموزش بازی انفجار آنلاین و شرطی، نیترو بهترین و پرمخاطب ‌ترین سایت انفجار ایرانی، نحوه برد و واقعیت ربات ها و ...
here for more information


very nice


very nice content



Anonymous said...

python training in bangalore | python online trainng
artificial intelligence training in bangalore | artificial intelligence online training
uipath training in bangalore | uipath online training
blockchain training in bangalore | blockchain online training

Krishna Chaubey said...

Bon article,

Pixel 4a deep discription | pixel 4a vs Nord | pixel 4a vs iPhone se

Anonymous said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog
Data science Training in bangalore
Aws Training In Bangalore
Hadoop Training In Bangalore
Devops Training In Bangalore
Iot Training in Bangalore

Hindifly said...

nice information
more information click here

Radley Co Tad said...

Great Article
Cloud Computing Projects

Networking Projects

Final Year Projects for CSE

JavaScript Training in Chennai

JavaScript Training in Chennai

The Angular Training covers a wide range of topics including Components, Angular Directives, Angular Services, Pipes, security fundamentals, Routing, and Angular programmability. The new Angular TRaining will lay the foundation you need to specialise in Single Page Application developer. Angular Training

Hindifly said...

Thanks for sharing very good information
Banking Awareness Quiz 2020

Hindifly said...

Benificial for Ibps po, Clerk, SBI clerk, PO, RRB PO, Cler and Other Competitive Examination
English Comprehension 2020

world Authentic News said...

Nice information provided in the article which is more useful for people who search for it

KITS Technologies said...

I value the article post.Much thanks again. Really Great.
install sheild online training
install sheild training
ios online training
ios training
Iot online training
Iot training
Java online training
Java training
Machine learning online training

Hindifly said...

What is Bitcoin & How to Buy Bitcoin

Kunal Thapa said...

Technology updates and inventions

Hindifly said...

What is NPA ( Non- Performing Assets )

Nadeem Technical said...

Great Article I think His SIte Owner Keep Doing Hard Work
Tamilrockers New Link

Claire said...

You might wanna check this website for more useful information....

Hindifly said...

Thanks for shairing this information
Statutory and Regulatory Provisions

Jerome Devu said...

Pretty Good Article!
At, we provide training in Data Science Training in Bangalore

Trenz24x7 said...

Thanks to admin to share this information Read Best Lyrics On The Go
South Indian
And Bhojpuri Song Lyrics

Aditya Singh said...

Nice information share

[Whatsapp Crash 2020] How to Crash someone's Whatsapp or Whatsapp Group | Hang anyone's whatsapp

4 Best Method Computer Se Malware aur Virus Remove Karne Ke Liye said...

Well, here is the solution. Garmin Express is a PC based software which you can and download and install on your Windows or Mac, to get the latest maps and updates. You can get it from the Garmin support website, and after following some simple instructions, you can get it in your device.

sam said...

if you have free time please visit us w who visit our site will surely benefit :) 카지노사이트 카지노사이트

itsbharatverma said...

Nice post bro For more hindi shayari click here

Nice information bro For Health related information visit here

Michael said...

Unknown said...

Personal finance management is the foundation of becoming a millionarie. If you cannot manage your finances, it is not possible that you will become rich one day. So, learn the art of personal finance by following the blog How to create a budget

Unknown said...

Are you interested in making passive money? One of the most easiest and less competitive method is google maps. Know how to Make money with google maps

Yoona said...

This is a inspiring great affection blog.I am amaze much pleased with your good work.
You put very helpful information. Keep blogging. Please do visit our website.
Keep it up! 카지노사이트

Clipping Path Best said...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely helpful information specially the last part 🙂 I care for such info much. I was seeking this certain information for a long time. Thank you and good luck.

WE are provide this services.
Clipping path Best
Photo Editing Service Provider
Photoshop Service
Clipping Path
Image Editing Service
Photoshop Editing Service

sabrina said...

Hi! I just would like to offer you a big thumbs up for the great info you have got here on this
Pls visit our website :)
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

15 August wishes said...

Very Good Information Share
Mahadev Status In Hindi

Quotes said...

excellent post .regards
Royal Enfield Quotes

Trini said...

What a terrific idea you have here! The way you deliver the information is really fantastic. Keep it up! Kindly visit our website too if you have some time. Thanks and have a good day!

카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Digital Zug said...

Clipping Xpert
Clipping Xpert India
Paragon Clipping Path
Clipping Path Service
Image Editing Company
Ecommerce Image Editing Service
Clipping path company
Clipping Path Service
Image Editing Company
Ecommerce Image Editing Service
Clipping path company
Clipping Path Service
Image Editing Company
Ecommerce Image Editing Service
Clipping path company

SAHANY said...

Very nice post thanks

LIZA said...

Excellent post. Please keep up the great work..‌ ‌카지노사이트‌ ‌


Thank you So much for sharing this useful information

Thank you So much for sharing this useful information

news said...

Thank you for sharing this information.
Among Us guide

Mohd Sharique said...

Wow, amazing post! Really engaging, thank you.

Python Training In Pune
python training institute in pune

joyce said...

Brilliant work! Hope you continue creating this kind of article. Try visiting our webpage.
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

JANE said...

I really enjoying reading this, such a nice blog. Keep it up!
And hey guys, I want to share our website. This is promising and worth reading.
i hope you visit our website

ravi said...

We have seen many blog but this the great one, Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would like to request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

birth certificate in delhi
birth certificate in noida
birth certificate in ghaziabad
birth certificate in gurgaon
birth certificate agent in delhi
marriage registration in delhi
marriage certificate in delhi
correction in 10th mark sheet
marriage registration in ghaziabad
marriage registration in gurgaon said...

Garmin Express Update is the most essential part after buying your GPS device. This helps in refreshing your device as per the latest maps update or other features from the company. Here will help you to update your Garmin express from which keeps on releasing new updates every year. And depending upon your operating system Mac OS or Windows system you can easily update your Garmin express.

Trini said...

Excellent! This blog of yours is really a motivation to many. Continue creating contents like this. Please spare a moment and visit our website too. Thank you!

카지노사이트 카지노사이트

LIZA said...

I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this 바카라사이트 i really injoying this.i want to share our website. this is promising and worth reading. i hope you our visit our website..‌ ‌카지노사이트

Yoona said...

You make good use of flavored words that make your article tasteless. Just Wow!
Please do visit our website too.
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Claire said...

This blog helps me a lot.Please make time to read, this may help you.
Click the link below....

JANE said...

I really enjoying reading this, such a nice blog. Keep it up!
And hey guys, I want to share our website. This is promising and worth reading.
i hope you visit our website

waseem said...

gogo anime Watch anime online in English. You can watch free series and movies online and English subtitles.

Lottery sambad is the Indian lottery system. The important and main thing which attracts the people to invest in this lottery is the number of prizes and size of the lottery. There are many other lotteries in India but sambad is a very popular lottery among the Indian people.

오늘도달리자 said...

I wanted to know about starting my web log.
I think you have what you need to set up, and you have a blog.


sabrina said...

This information is worth everyone’s attention. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up!
Please visit our website:
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Vaibhav Tripathi said...

Heyy, Great and Informative Content ! Looking forward for more stuff like this ! Also Check: Educational Touch for such amazing content.

kajalkapoor said...
Uttarakhand Escort Service | Uttarakhand Call Girls
Get Escort Service in Uttarakhand at low price by Miss Kajal 000000000. Our escorts agency offers luxurious and beautiful Uttarakhand female model escorts
Uttarakhand call girls, call girls in Uttarakhand, young girls, call girl Uttarakhand, escorts in Dehradun, escort service in dehradun, dehradun call girls, dehradun escort, escort in dehradun, dehradun escort service, hariyana escorts service, dehradun independent Escorts , dehradun escorts, escort service in dehradun, dehradun escorts agency.

Technogeekscs said...

This concept is a good way to enhance knowledge. thanks for sharing..
Data Science
ETL Testing
Python Online Classes

MISHELLE said...

AMAZING!!! This blog presents a very valuable information. Keep up the good work! Visit our website too. Thanks!

안전놀이터 안전놀이터 said...

FuboTV focuses on channels distributing live sports and various other services. Select the signing in option of using the activation code. FuboTv app is available on most of the android and iOS stores.Fubo activate code through enter code For latest updates.

Anonymous said...

Mobile Review

Technogeekscs said...

This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts.
Data Science
ETL Testing
Python Online Classes

By Admin said...


No mistakes for getting Google adsense Approval

amour said...

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. Visit our website too. 바카라사이트 바카라사이트

joyce said...

This website is very interesting! I love the way you write articles. It's very cool! If you like, you can try checking out our website.
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Yoona said...

You Make Me Smile. I want to tell you how much I appreciated your clearly written and thought-provoking article. Keep creating helpful info. Keep it up!
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Yoona said...

You Make Me Smile. I want to tell you how much I appreciated your clearly written and thought-provoking article. Keep creating helpful info. Keep it up!
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

MISHELLE said...

GREAT JOB !!! This blog presents a very valuable information. Keep up the good work! Visit our website too. Thanks!

안전놀이터 안전놀이터

Akhilesh Kumar said...

Really Nice Information It's Very Helpful All Govt Scheme Checkout Here
Meri Fasal Mera Byora
Shadi Anudan


Merry christmas

Anas Siddiki said...


Good knowledge post for this information

Unknown said...

If you have to live stream shows upon iPhone/iPad download Hulu application and introduce it upon your device. Upon productive commencement sign in to your Hulu scrap book and inauguration watching. Through you can sign in to your Hulu account pick your contraption.

sabrina said...

Amazing!!! This blog presents a very valuable information. Keep up the good work! Visit our website too. Thankyou!
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

R ADK said...

Software IT Coaching Center in ChennaiOrganic Chemistry tutor

ram said...

Worth reading! Our experts also have given detailed inputs about these trainings & courses! Presenting here for your reference. Do checkout
oracle sql training in chennai & enjoy learning more about it.

Fubotv Activate said...

You can avail of unlimited streaming as FuboTv app gives seven days free trial. When you get access to, you get access to view more than 200 channels, and it has everything you require in any streaming services. fubotv activate is a crucial process when you chose fubo for the first time.

sabrina said...

Thank you for some other informative web site. I truly appreciate this post. I¡¦ve been looking all over for this!
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Devi said...

Thank you for posting informative insights, I think we have got some more information to share with! Do check out Big data training in chennai and let us know your thoughts. Let’s have great learning!

sha sha said...

poker IDN dan live IDN casino kami hadirkan untuk anda yang senang bermain casino online. Nikmati judi casino live sexy dealer. kunjungi kami di

Joker said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Joker said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Yoona said...

Hey there it awesome to read and explore your blog my friend. Keep creating like this! Thanks for sharing!
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

Best Training Institute said...

Thanks For sharing a nice post about ASP secutity Course.It is very helpful and for us.

sap security training in bangalore
sap security class in bangalore
learn sap security in bangalore

Best Training Institute said...

Really Nice Information It's Very Helpful All courses Checkout Here.
Sap Apo training in bangalore

AYA said...

A very successful and good idea. This is really interesting and helpful, because of many informations on this article. Thank you guys for sharing this for us. Just want to recommend our site, its really good enough for everyone to visit, just click the link below: 카지노사이트 카지노사이트

ciwuxi said...

our blog
our blog

Techno Sunil said...

What is cyber security in Hindi ? Antivirus kya hota hai ?

Techno Sunil said...

Technology Artical

Yoona said...

After exploring a number of the articles on your blog, I truly appreciate your way of blogging, I can't help myself to save it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my website too.
카지노사이트 카지노사이트

SixD Engineering Solutions Pvt Ltd said...

I am really happy with your blog because your article is very unique and powerful for new.
Plant Engineering Services
Offshore Engineering Services India

Technogeekscs said...

This concept is a good way to enhance knowledge. thanks for sharing..
Data Science Course in Pune

Alisheraz said...

Create Ecommerce Website

Thanks for sharing your knowledge...

dfgfhft said...

dapatkan bonus seminggu sekali berdasarkan turnover. kunjungi kami di bandar slot joker123 resmi dan terpercaya

AYA said...

The article that you shared to us are absolutely impressive. This is fun, enjoyable and we have learned a lot of ideas. Just wanna try our site? Feel free to visit, here's the link: 카지노사이트
Https:// 카지노사이트

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 400 of 566   Newer› Newest»